May 25, 2007

Book Review - Pakistan: Sovereignty Lost

Buried in debt
National debt is a serious subject which must be discussed in a sober rather than sensational manner, writes Dr Muhammad Reza Kazimi
Dawn: Books and Authors, May 20, 2007

Book Review: Pakistan: Sovereignty Lost
By Shahid ur Rehman

Shahid ur Rehman, a veteran journalist known for his economic and diplomatic reports, is correspondent for Kyodo News Agency of Japan. His other books include Who Owns Pakistan? and Long Road to Chagai

Pakistan is burdened with debt. This constricts its diplomatic and security options. There have been attempts by previous governments to liquidate the debt. Resumption of aid following Pakistan’s joining the ‘War Against Terror’ gave the impression that the debt burden had been greatly relieved. Shahid ur Rehman assures us that it has not. The Introduction of his book highlights his main contentions and it is here that he shifts the burden of guilt from economic to political decisions. It is an indictment of our country’s early leadership. Some of these observations are factual and correct but even here, the documentation is not adequate, which prevents his observations from acquiring context.

Shahid ur Rehman says that Pakistan first lost its sovereignty immediately after its independence, when the Quaid-i-Azam sought a $2 billion economic assistance from the United States (P.15). The background to this is that the US was the only country to send a delegation to attend the Independence celebrations of Pakistan, while the USSR was the only country not to congratulate Pakistan on its creation. The Indian government had withheld Pakistan’s share of its financial assets. The 17 per cent which was paid after Gandhi’s protests was barely sufficient to meet our initial expenditure.

In an investigative treatise, it is necessary to mention the primary cause of the events described. According to the author, Liaquat Ali Khan and Khwaja Nazim uddin renewed the request only two days after Liaquat’s assassination. It needed to be ascertained whether Liaquat’s signature was genuine, since this is an assertion which is at odds with other US documents. Liaquat’s meeting with the US envoy Avra Warren only four days before his assassination; had been contentious. Warren had asked for Pakistan to contribute towards Middle East defence. Liaquat made the contribution contingent on a Kashmir solution and not on $2 billion. In fact, Liaquat was broaching a joint defence with Iran and Egypt, against the western bloc.

Shahid ur Rehman tells us that in 1952, wheat imported from the US was transported on camel carts with “Thank you America” written on the signs hanging from the animals’ necks. This, by itself is correct, but here one is tempted to register a counter complaint:

“Not long ago, while one of the authors was in Pakistan, our economic mission delivered a shipment of American tractors. Within a few days, it was commonly accepted throughout the countryside that the tractors had been given by Russia” (A Factual Epilogue: The Ugly American, P.282)

Shahid ur Rehman in his Introduction blames Ayub Khan for the grant of the Badaber Base. Further on, he himself refers to the acrimonious correspondence between Ayub and Lyndon B. Johnson over its closure: “I give not a fig for Pakistan except as its interests are ours” (P.17). Earlier McConaughy wrote: “The fight to the finish would destroy Pakistan’s military capability, which is not in American interests” (British Papers, P.381). Every envoy is meant to consider the interest of his or her own country and not the country of accreditation. Clearly, McConaughy was answering the charge that he was being sympathetic to the country to which he was assigned.

Under the heading ‘Mystery of Liaquat’s visit to the US’ (P.30), Shahid ur Rehman persists in the face of overwhelming documentary evidence to the contrary, that Liaquat used USSR’s invitation to cadge an invitation from the US. But it is another fact that the USSR, after having extended the invitation, never set the dates. Before embarking for USA; on American soil and on his return, Liaquat reiterated that he had accepted Stalin’s invitation but he could only go when the dates were set.

But before rendering judgments, one must keep in sight, that even now, the India-US Nuclear Treaty and Russia’s supply of five nuclear reactors to India are proceeding simultaneously. It is naïve to think that the same conditions that apply to India would also apply to Pakistan, which brings us back to the advantages accruing to India, and the disadvantages accruing to Pakistan at the time of its creation. To blame the founding fathers instead of recognising the predicament in which the new country found itself, is quite a distortion.

National debt is a serious subject which must be discussed in a sober rather than sensational manner. It was found necessary because, when the author comes to his subject, he is on firm ground. In a situation when the people of Pakistan are kept from knowing the extent of their debt, when the loan is staggering despite the respite granted to Pakistan for its cooperation in the ‘War Against Terror’, these facts need to be made public.

Shahid ur Rehman reveals that 1989-90 was the first financial year during which debt repayment came first in the federal budget, getting ahead of defence and development (P.74). During the same year, three packages were negotiated with the IMF — all negotiated by unelected governments but implemented by elected governments. Since 1990, Pakistan is paying $39 million every year to encash one National Highway Authority bond worth $22 million and “nobody knows when, how and why these bonds were issued” (P.84). It would take $780 million for bonds having a face value of $440 million by 2010, which is not too far away. Now the debt incurred for building highways is not the same as the debt incurred for keeping the economy afloat in the initial stages. We must differentiate between the loans contracted before and after the Korean War, when the element of compulsion had receded.

Apart from the amounts of the loans contracted, the other aspect is that since information is not shared, there is no accountability. For example, Dr A.R. Kemal suspects that the government was reporting commercial debts repayment, but not the commercial debt contracted. A table provided by the author reveals that Pakistan to date has contracted $79 billion and repaid $70 million. They are shocking figures.

In conclusion, we are constrained to remark that such an important book should not have been produced in such a slipshod manner. We learn that what Ziaul Haq had staged was not a coup but a “coupe”. Similarly the back cover says that the premier had promised to come to the premier of the book.



Pakistan joined the World Bank on July 11, 1950, and the Auditor-General Yaqub Shah was appointed the first Pakistani representative to The World Bank.

A team of World Bank officials visited Pakistan in 1951 and offered $60 million for irrigation purposes, the rehabilitation of railways, extension of telecommunication and hydro projects.

Pakistan contracted the first loan in its history — $27 million from the World Bank for Pakistan Railways on February 22, 1952. But it was the first loan from the United States signed in December 1952 that changed the economic, security and political landscape for all times to come.

In 1951, India, hit by a famine sought two million tons of wheat from the United States leading to the Indian Emergency Flood Act signed by President Truman on June 19, 1951. It envisaged that a nearly $5 million interest would be used to bring Indian students, professors and technicians to the United States and for free ocean transportation of relief supplies to India given by individuals and private organisations.

In 1952, Pakistan was also hit by a food shortage earning the ‘gourmet’ Prime Minister Khwaja Nazim uddin the nickname of Quaid-i-Qilat (leader of shortages).

The government approached the United States for assistance, and negotiations which led to an agreement for the import of one million tons of wheat under a $15 million commercial loan provided by USEXIM. The agreement was signed at a ceremony in the White House on September 7, 1952, witnessed by President Truman. Ambassador Muhammad Ali Bogra signed on behalf of Pakistan.

Subsequent developments revealed that the shortage was artificial and as soon as imported wheat started reaching Pakistan, the hoarded wheat resurfaced. When 600,000 tons of wheat had arrived, the government asked the US to stop further shipments.

Using the food shortage as a pretext, Ghulam Mohammad sacked Prime Minister Nazim uddin on April 17, 1953. According to various accounts, Nazim uddin was held incommunicado, his telephone lines severed to prevent him from appealing to the Queen in whose name the governor-general was ruling Pakistan.

Nazim uddin is reported to have remarked in helplessness that when he was governor-general, the power lied with the prime minister, now that he was the prime minister, the governor-general was wielding the real power.

Mohammad Ali Bogra was imported from Washington to become the prime minister. He was the first rolling stone of Pakistani politics to rise meteorically by switching over parties and loyalties. When Pakistan was born, he supported Hussein Shaheed Suharwardy in the election of the leader of the house in the East Pakistan Legislative Assembly against Khwaja Nazim uddin.

Nazim uddin won. Bogra changed his allegiance to Nazim uddin and managed to secure the ambassadorship to the United States. Mehmood Ali, a veteran of the Pakistan Movement, said the following about Mohammad Ali Bogra.

“In the power struggle in Pakistan after the assassination of Prime Minister Liaquat Ali Khan and the illegal and unconstitutional dismissal of Khwaja Nazim uddin, Mohammad Ali Bogra changed over to the Ghulam Mohammad-Iskandar Mirza-Ayub Khan axis backed by a foreign power and succeeded in stealing the office of the prime minister of Pakistan.”

As ambassador to the United States, Bogra had signed the cherished deal for one million tons of wheat and was inducted as prime minister before it started arriving in Pakistan. The US wheat was transported from the port on camel carts with “Thank you America” hanging from the camels necks and its arrival was celebrated at a glittering ceremony in Karachi on July 3, 1953. It was the biggest ceremony ever in the history of the metropolis chaired by Prime Minister Bogra.


JAHANA said...

Birmingham Web Design
Birmingham web designing is a Birmingham based blog which has been designed by Suhanasoft, and Indian web Design Company. The company provides website design, web development and search Engine Optimization services at affordable prices. Our creative design and developing secure website has made us popular among our clients. We have developed several websites from demark.

Anonymous said...

Urteter nuytre:

Anonymous said...

Seo needs a very good search engine optimizer plan. Simply one of these methods can make a giant distinction in your sites place and firm your website brings you. как появилась фамилия загута| single products guess handbags| как появилась фамилия загретдинов| with her pace unless they've got a lot of money Click Here

Anonymous said...

Pick Most Awesome christian louboutin boots now Yourself
Christian Louboutin is the reason a native born Parisian.He liked designing contrasted sketch maps when it comes to running footwear and jake started to do implant after Charles Jourdan in the seventies.After 10 yearsworking for Chanel further Yves Saint Laurent,Christian Louboutin set up an easier first just Louboutin shoes?store sway 1992,starting his career.Lets Choose notably incredible christian louboutin britain for a homeowner's erotic mommy [url=]christian louboutin outlet[/url]. factual is straightforward that no very feminine,not unique in shape,but also effect all its vibrant red christian louboutin .This may represent fictional to wear a frivolous motives the moment again of course,in the next prudence and elegant way.If you do not intend to make a yielding appearance,wearing that hope is subversive,and let others since the twos of startle [url=]christian louboutin discount heels[/url].

Anonymous said...

Well I sincerely enjoyed studying it. This information provided by you is very constructive for correct planning.
my site >

Anonymous said...

It’s actually a great and useful piece of information. I’m
glad that you

shared this helpful information with us.
Please keep us informed like this. Thanks for

Feel free to visit my web blog :: 4 star hotels in barcelona spain near beach

Anonymous said...

Hey very cool blog!! Man .. Excellent .. Amazing .. I will bookmark your

site and take the feeds also…I am happy to find a lot of useful

information here in the post, we need work out more strategies
in this regard, thanks for

sharing. . . . . .
Feel free to surf my blog post :: spanier hired

Anonymous said...

I precisely wanted to thank you so much once
more. I am not sure what I might have sorted out without
the thoughts provided by you on

my subject. It actually was a very daunting

concern in my view, but noticing the professional mode you
treated that

forced me to weep for fulfillment. I will be grateful for your help and even
hope that

you comprehend what a powerful job you are always

teaching other individuals all through a web site.

likely you've never met any of us.
My webpage -

Anonymous said...

I loved as much as you'll receive carried out right here. The sketch is attractive, your authored

material stylish. nonetheless, you command get got an impatience

over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly

the same nearly a lot often inside case you shield this increase.
Also see my website :: madrid stock exchange website

Anonymous said...

I’ll immediately snatch your rss feed as I

can't find your e-mail subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do

you have any? Kindly let me understand so that I may just subscribe. Thanks.
Here is my webpage ; www.diysolarheatingspain.Com

Anonymous said...

Hi, Neat post. There is a problem with your web site in
internet explorer, would check

this… IE still is the market leader and a good portion of people will miss your excellent writing due
to this problem.
Review my weblog :

Anonymous said...

Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that
it's truly

informative. I am going to watch out for brussels. I’ll be grateful if you continue

this in future. Many people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!
Feel free to surf my website ;利用者:ZoniaCarroll83

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure why but this website is loading extremely slow for

me. Is anyone else having this problem or is it a issue on my end? I'll check
back later and

see if the problem still exists.
Also see my site :: 3 day diet plan toast

Anonymous said...

you've gotten an incredible blog here! would you prefer to make some invite posts on my weblog?
my web page -

Anonymous said...

I have recently started a web site, the info you provide on this website has helped me tremendously.
Thank you for all of your time & work.
My web page ; sealing terracotta tiles spain

Anonymous said...

Woah! I'm really loving the template/theme of this site. It's simple, yet effective.

lot of times it's very hard to get that "perfect balance" between user friendliness and visual appearance. I must say you have done a great job with this. In addition,

the blog loads extremely quick for me on Chrome. Outstanding Blog!
My blog -

Anonymous said...

Greetings I am so excited I found your website,
I really found you by mistake, while I was browsing on
Google for something

else, Regardless I am here now and would just like to say thanks for a marvelous post and a all round

thrilling blog (I also love the theme/design),
I don’t have time to read through it all at the minute
but I have book-marked it and also

added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read a lot more, Please do keep up the awesome job.
my site ::

Anonymous said...

Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with

Search Engine Optimization? I'm trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I'm not seeing very

results. If you know of any please share. Appreciate it!
Here is my weblog :Участник:MedaLee1981

Anonymous said...

I'm not sure exactly why but this site is loading incredibly slow for

me. Is anyone else having this problem or is it a issue on my end? I'll check back later on and

see if the problem still exists.
Feel free to visit my web-site ::

Anonymous said...

Wow, wonderful ωеblog ѕtructure! How lengthy have you evег been blogging
for? you made running a blog look easу. Τhe full look of your website is ωonderful, let
alone the contеnt matеriаl!

Here is my webpagе; dallas seo company

Anonymous said...

wonderful points altogether, you just gained
a brand new reader.

What would you recommend in regards to your post that you made some
days ago? Any positive?

My page ...

Anonymous said...

An attention-grabbing discussion is value comment.


believe that it's best to write more on this matter, it might not be a taboo subject however usually persons are not enough to talk on such topics. To the next. Cheers

Also visit my web page

Anonymous said...

Fine way of explaining, and good paragraph to obtain data on the topic of my presentation focus, which i am going to deliver in institution
of higher education.

my blog; shooting targets silhouette

Anonymous said...

Good day! I just wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the
great information you’ve got right here on this post. I might be coming again
to your blog for more soon.

My blog are semi sweet chocolate chips dairy free

Anonymous said...

Hiya! I just want to give a huge thumbs up for the great data you’ve gotten here on this post.
I will be coming back to your blog for extra soon.

my web-site; new seoul garden beaverton

Anonymous said...

Hey! I just wish to give a huge thumbs up for the good data you have right here on
this post. I will likely be coming back to your blog for extra soon.

Also visit my web-site :: SEO收費

Anonymous said...

Expert's Guide To purchasing A A digital Projector Pertaining to Education Or maybe Business

Here is my web blog Epson Powerlite Home Cinema 3010 price