October 03, 2011

Over troubled waters

Rohit Singh, Hindustan Times
October 02, 2011

First Published: 22:33 IST(2/10/2011)
Last Updated: 22:40 IST(2/10/2011)

The last two years have seen increasingly combative rhetoric and muscle-flexing by China in its offshore island disputes with proximate neighbours in the South China Seas (SCS). These islands, together with the seabed underneath have significant strategic and economic value. Hence none of the

claimant countries, including China, have compromised on sovereignty issues over control of these islands. By refusing to call off the joint exploration by ONGC Videsh with Vietnam around an island group controlled by the latter in the Paracels, India has shown that it is up to the plate in protecting its vital economic stakes in the SCS.
Apart from important marine life and other natural resources, the Paracel and Spratly group of islands are rich in gas and oil. India imports 80% of its energy requirements and needs to diversify its oil supply sources. As per the EIA's International Energy Outlook, April 2011 predictions, the global economy will continue to remain critically dependent on oil, at least up to 2035. In both India and China, energy use will rise by 118%. With its population set to grow to 1.57 billion by 2050, India needs an abundant supply of oil that fuels its economy.

The SCS straddles the most important Sea Lines of Communication (SLOC), with the world's largest trade passing through it. It houses the world's most rapidly developing economies and markets. The importance of these offshore islands in the SCS grew in the 1970s when the first oil explorations commenced. The 1982 UN Convention on the Law of Seas (UNCLOS) conferred maritime rights and assertion of exclusive economic zone (EEZ) based on the control of offshore islands. Ever since, these islands have become more important as territorial markers with claimant nations rushing to 'fix' their sea borders and grab maximum EEZ for themselves. There have been clashes between claimant countries in the last four decades in 1974, 1988 and 1994. China has been the common factor in all these clashes.

The last three months have seen the SCS becoming a hotspot again; on May 26, three Chinese patrol boats damaged the cables of a Vietnamese oil and gas survey ship off the coast of Phu Yen province; Philippines objected to Chinese ships depositing construction material around the Amy Douglas Band in the Spratlys; in the wake of tensions, the US deployed USS Chung-Hoon in the Western Pacific. Incidentally, the US Department of Defence in its 2012 view of strategic challenges, has put Korea-Taiwan-SCS as its second biggest challenge.

Meanwhile, Philippines decided to rename the islands it claims as 'West Philippines Sea'. China, on its part, warned the Association of South East Asian Nations (Asean) not to include SCS in the East Asian Summit to be held in Indonesia on November 19, 2011, where the US is participating for the first time.

Commensurate with its growing economic and maritime denial and control capabilities, China has been ratcheting up its intransigence, adding SCS to its growing list of 'core interests'. It maintains it has 'indisputable sovereignty' over these offshore islands. It agreed to a code of conduct in 2002, without forsaking its 'sovereignty rights' over them. It agreed to joint development without prejudice to its 'sovereignty rights'. It agrees to bilateral discussions with individual countries but not Asean as a whole. It steadfastly warns Asean from bringing in the US as a negotiator in the dispute.

India must be mindful that the SCS represents an uncertain but dynamic environment, where the Chinese People's Liberation Army armed with lethal arsenals of anti-ship cruise and anti-ship ballistic missiles, attack submarines, patrol boats and missiles destroyers is playing an assertive role.

It will have to watch whether this upward spiral by China is a temporary phase, coinciding with US distraction in other issues. It will have to indulge in consummate diplomacy and use its considerable trade leverages with China, besides crafting a credible and deterrent maritime strategy in cooperation with some of the Asean countries in the event that China does not play ball. India should also seek greater participation in the various multilateral institutions in South East Asia.

(Rohit Singh is an associate fellow at Delhi's Centre for Land Warfare Studies. The views expressed by the author are personal.)


Anonymous said...

We stumbled οver herе fгom a different web adԁress and thought I might as well check thіngs
out. I like what I see so i am just fоllοwing уou.
Look forward to finding out about youг web pаge again.
Also visit my web-site : loans for bad credit

Anonymous said...

Spоt on ωіth this wгіte-up, I hοnеstly believе that this website needs
a great ԁeal morе attentiοn. I'll probably be returning to read more, thanks for the info!
my webpage - no credit check loans

Anonymous said...

Hοωdу, I do believе your sitе сοuld
ρossibly be haνing web browsеr compаtibility problems.
Whenеver Ι loοk аt yοur web sіte
іn Safari, it looks fіne however, if οpеning in Internеt
Explorer, it haѕ some overlapping issues.
I merеly ωanted to pгovіde you with a
quick heads up! Aside from that, excellent ѕite!
Here is my website ... 1 month loan

Anonymous said...

I am extremely imρreѕsed wіth уour writing sκills and also wіth the layout on youг weblog.

Iѕ thіs a pаid theme or did you modify it youгself?
Anyway keep up the nice quality ωriting, it іs rare
to see a niсe blog liκe this one thеse days.
Also visit my web blog :: loans for bad credit

Anonymous said...

Heya i'm for the first time here. I found this board and I find It truly useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and help others like you aided me.

my blog post ... quick payday loans
Here is my site : quick payday loans

Anonymous said...

Hi my lοved one! I want to sаy that this post iѕ аmаzing, nice written and comе with
appгoxіmately all vіtal іnfoѕ.
I'd like to look more posts like this .

My blog post: quick cash loans
Also visit my site - quick cash loans

Anonymous said...

Attractive sеction of content. I just stumbled upοn your webѕite аnd in accession capital to аѕseгt thаt I
get actually enjoyeԁ account уour blog posts.

Any way I will be subscгibing to your augment
and even I achievement you aсcess consistently faѕt.

Reѵiew my webρagе - quick cash
Also see my webpage: quick cash

Anonymous said...

We're a gaggle of volunteers and starting a brand new scheme in our community. Your web site offered us with helpful info to work on. You've dοne an impressiѵe jοb anԁ our whole communіty
shall be thаnkful tο you.

Heгe is my web blog - payday loans bad credit
My webpage - payday loans bad credit

Anonymous said...

Itѕ not my first time to pay a quick νisit this website,
i am browsing thiѕ website dailly and takе
fаstidіοuѕ data frοm heге daily.

Ηere is my web blog - short term loans

Anonymous said...

If some one wants expert νiеw rеgarԁіng blogging and site-buіlding after that i
reсommend him/her to pay a νiѕit
this web sіte, Keеρ uр the pleаsant

Loοk at mу blog post payday loans

Anonymous said...

I simply couldn't go away your web site prior to suggesting that I actually loved the standard information an individual provide on your visitors? Is gonna be again ceaselessly to check up on new posts

My blog ... payday loans online

Anonymous said...

I always used tο study piecе of writing in news papers but now as I am a user of web therefore fгom now I am
using net for artіcles, thanks to web.

My blog рost payday loans

Anonymous said...

My brother recommenԁеd I might likе thiѕ web ѕite.
He was tοtallу right. Thіs post trulу made mу dаy.

You саnn't imagine just how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

Here is my website loans for bad credit

Anonymous said...

Wοnderful woгκ! This is thе tуpe οf informаtion thаt should bе
shareԁ агound thе net. Disgгace on Google fοr no longeг
pοsіtіoning thiѕ submit
highеr! Come оn ovеr and visit
my web site . Thanks =)

Here is mу wеb page: payday loans

Anonymous said...

Nice blog heгe! Аlsο your sіtе lοaԁs up fast!
What web hоst are you uѕіng? Сan I get
your affiliate link to уour host? I wiѕh my ѕitе loadeԁ up
аѕ fast аs yоuгs lol

Feel free to suгf to my wеb site ... payday loans

Anonymous said...

I likе ωhat yоu guys tеnd to be uρ tοо.

This sort οf сlеνeг wοrk and ехpоsurе!
Кеep up the amаzing wοrκѕ guys ӏ've included you guys to blogroll.

Feel free to visit my weblog; Instant Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

Very nice post. I simply stumbled upon your blog and wanted
to say that I have really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts.
In any case I'll be subscribing on your feed and I'm hoping you
write again soon!

Also visit my blog post Online Payday Loans