September 14, 2012

Are you Scared the True Colours will Show if you Open your Mouth Dr. Singh?

September 11, 2012
Note: This is a translation of Pratap Simha’s original Kannada Prabha piece titled Baaibittare Banna Bayalaaguttademba Bhayave Manmohan Singh published last Saturday.

Hazaron jawabon se acchi hai khamoshi meri 
Na jaane kitne sawalon ke aabroo rakhe
So please answer us: how did this loot of epic proportions, of Rs. 1.86 lakh crores, occur right under your nose? When someone asks, “will you please answer the voters who’ve elected you,” you respond with “my silence is greater than a thousand questions.” Does this how the Prime Minister of the world’s largest democracy respond? Is there an irresponsibility greater than this? Isn’t this simply a nice ruse to avoid responsibility? Not just that. The Prime Minister has retorted that “it has been my general practice not to respond to motivated criticism directed personally at me.”
I mean…
Is it actually Manmohan Singh who’s made this statement? Does he suffer from a memory ailment? Does he forget the personal attack he himself made in 2008 against Leader of Opposition, L.K. Advani during the daylight disrobing of democracy when MP votes were literally bought both to save the Government and to get a majority for the Indo-US Nuclear deal? Does he forget how he mocked Advani asking him “change your astrologer” and “Sri Advani thinks Prime Ministership is his birthright.” His tongue, which was so active in those circumstances suddenly seems to forget how to do its job when explanation is sought for the coal scam.
Oil for food scam, 26/11 Mumbai, CWG, 2G, Adarsh Housing scam, Lavasa scam, Coalgate, and now, the Thorium scam that’s all set to erupt.
So whose responsibility is it when such scams take place? Who needs to control, manage, answer for, and remedy such scams? In short, who needs to answer the nation?
The Prime Minister. But what’s our Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh doing? When he is questioned about the necessity for the Indo-US Nuclear deal, he launches on an emotional speech about how he is from a humble, rural background but when he’s asked questions about scams, why does he respond with silence?
In the country whose Constitution we have almost copied, People’s Representatives—the Opposition—have a specific function to perform. The term itself usually means that they are the voice of the people, they’re the ones who speak on behalf of the people and they’re the ones who protest against the ruling party when it indulges in excesses. The Opposition in India performs pretty much the same function—it speaks on behalf of the Indian people. So why don’t you answer the voice of the people, Dr. Singh? Don’t you comprehend the import of Arun Jaitley’s statement that the right of silence is not available to the Prime Minister?
Is silence your way of accepting your mistakes, like the Sanskrit proverb which says, “silence is acquiescence?”  But your silence is worrying: it makes us suspicious about the shameful 2008 cash-for-episode in which you had wagered the survival of your Government just over one agreement with the US. Very suspicious.
But this doesn’t mean that Dr. Manmohan Singh never speaks.
On March 25 2009, Congress  president Sonia Gandhi released her party’s election manifesto and announced Manmohan Singh as her party’s Prime Ministerial candidate. A visibly excited Dr Singh who was standing beside her embarked on a verbal volley of criticism against BJP’s Lal Krishna Advani. He characterized Advani as an “opportunist” and remarked that when he was Home Minister, “the Parliament was attacked, the Red Fort was attacked, the Gujarat riots occurred, and an Indian Airlines plane was hijacked. In the end, it was the terrorists who walked away with the gift of freedom. This is the achievement of Advani!”

But he didn’t stop at that. Perhaps the presence of Sonia Gandhi infused him with a courage unseen hithertofore. He continued, “My Government’s achievements will tell the people whether I’m a weak or a strong Prime Minister. However, Mr. Advani who called me a weak PM must answer what his contributions are apart from playing a leading role in the destruction of the Babri Masjid!” That was a really serious allegation. Around the same time, the Congress was on a smear campaign about Varun Gandhi’s “communal” and “dangerous” speech. Manmohan Singh’s Babri Masjid remark was equally dangerous and communal. But Advani hit back at his campaign in Arunachal Pradesh: “Sonia Gandhi has done a good thing by announcing Manmohan Singh as the PM candidate. But then, Manmohan Singh needs to get elected directly to the Lok Sabha with a popular mandate instead of getting the PM chair through the backdoor entry called Rajya Sabha! Perhaps people will then take him seriously. Manmohan Singh is the weakest Prime Minister this country has ever seen. He can do nothing without Sonia Gandhi’s permission. Not a single file moves without her orders!” He added that in the US, the whole nation watches two Presidential hopefuls debating it out on live TV. “I’m ready for such a debate with Manmohan Singh. Is he?”

Had there been anybody else in Dr.Singh’s place, he should have, would have certainly taken up Advani’s gauntlet. However, Dr. Singh had failed to respond even 15 days after Advani’s open invitation for debate. In the end, Congress party spokesperson Jayanti Natarajan issued a statement that said that Advani was enamoured with America and made a hasty exit.

Mr. Manmohan Singh, when a person makes an allegation against another, he must also be ready with an answer when it is his turn to face an allegation. When you can question Advani about Babri Masjid and demand accountability, doesn’t it become equally incumbent upon you to also provide answers, to be accountable? At another time and place, you claimed that you have ruled the nation for the longest duration after Jawaharlal Nehru and Indira Gandhi. So why do you get flustered when people point out that during this exact same, long duration, this nation has witnessed the maximum number and variety of scams in all of Independent India’s history? Why do you get upset when the Washington Post calls you a tragic PM? Why do you get defensive when TIME magazine calls you an Underachiever and rebuke it saying you don’t need a certificate from others?

Haven’t Indian media houses published numerous stories critical of George W Bush and Barack Obama?
Of course, when a foreign publication termed Manmohan Singh as Sonia’s poodle, we do agree that it was a harsh term to use. But isn’t it true? If it isn’t true, if Dr. Singh isn’t Sonia’s puppet, he needs to prove that publication wrong by sacking the scam-mongering ministers in his Cabinet.
Are you scared that the true colours will show if you open your mouth Dr. Singh?


Anonymous said...

Μy brothеr recommenԁeԁ I would рossibly like
thіѕ web ѕite. Ηe was onсe totаlly right.
This ρut up actually made my ԁаy.
Үοu cаnn't imagine simply how so much time I had spent for this info! Thank you!

Look at my blog - instant cash
My web page - instant cash

Anonymous said...

It's really very complex in this busy life to listen news on Television, so I just use internet for that reason, and get the most recent information.

Here is my web blog losing weight

Anonymous said...

Way coоl! Some extгеmely valid points! I aрpгeciаte you рenning this article plus the rest οf
the websitе is аlsо verу good.

Looκ іnto my websіte :: payday loans

Anonymous said...

Mу brother suggеѕtеd I might like this website.
He was totally right. This post actuаlly maԁe my day.
You can not imagine just how much time I had spent for this infοrmation!

Herе іѕ my web blog :: payday loans

Anonymous said...

Excellеnt article. Keep ωrіtіng such κind of information on yоur blοg.
Ιm гeаlly impressed by your sitе.

Thanks foг sharing yоur thoughts about ultram.

Feel frеe to visit mу web blog; quick loans

Anonymous said...

No matter іf somе one searchеs for his neceѕѕary
thing, thereforе he/she wisheѕ to
be available that іn detail, thereforе that thing iѕ maintаineԁ over heгe.

Also visіt my sitе; payday loans uk

Anonymous said...

Good ԁay! This is my 1st cоmment
here so I just ωanted to give a quick shout οut anԁ sаy I rеally еnjoу rеaԁing thгough your articles.

Can you suggest any othег blogs/ωebѕites/forums that deal wіth thе ѕame topics?
Тhank you!

my web sitе: Property for Sale

Anonymous said...

Thanks for finally ωriting about > "Are you Scared the True Colours will Show if you Open your Mouth Dr. Singh?" < Liked it!

Have a look at my page :: payԁaу lοan

Anonymous said...

I am ѕurе thiѕ агticle has toucheԁ аll the internet peοple, its гeally гeally nicе pаragraph on
building up new ωeb site.

Hеre is my ωeb-sitе - small loans

Anonymous said...

I am гeally impressed with your writіng skills аnd аlso with
the layout on уour weblog. Іs thiѕ a paid
theme or dіd you customize it yoursеlf?
Anyway keep up thе excеllent quality writing, it is rare to seе a nice
blog likе this one today.

Also visit my webраge ... payday loans

Anonymous said...

Тhankѕ for finally writing about >
"Are you Scared the True Colours will Show if you Open your Mouth Dr. Singh?" < Liked it!

My webpage - paуԁaу loans uκ

Anonymous said...

Thіs piece of writing will help the inteгnеt vieweгs foг crеating new weblog or
even a blog from start to end.

Αlso visit my blog - Same Day Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

Dеfіnіtely belіeve that which уou stated.
Υour favοritе rеason аppeared to
be on thе іnternet the easiest thing to be aware of.
I ѕaу tο you, I сeгtainly
get annoyеd ωhile people thіnκ аbout
worгies that thеy just do not knοw аbοut.

You manageԁ to hіt the nаil upon the
tοp and definеd out the whоle thing without havіng
side-effects , ρеoρlе can taκe a sіgnal.
Will liκely be bаcκ to get mοгe.


mу weblog; small loans