March 06, 2013

Wharton and Modi: Political gamesmanship won over business savvy

Last updated on: March 06, 2013 11:53 IST

'I agonise for these students that only desired to create a platform to discuss India's [ Images ] challenges and opportunities for growth. The students and the Wharton administration must learn the lessons of consequences even as they seek redemption that can be theirs with the right moves forward, argues Dr Aseem Shukla.

The Wharton India Economic Forum, a completely business student organised event, leverages the weighty Wharton imprimatur and has been a signature event in Philadelphia, the United States, for seventeen years, basking in the media spotlight.

This year, that spotlight is more a glare because of a profound and disturbing (mis)handling of an invitation to their chief guest, Narendra Modi [ Images ].

These students showed savvy in inviting Modi, elected thrice as the chief minister of Gujarat.
Known as one of the most effective managers and leaders of a state, when other states in India as well as the central government are rocked by scandals, riddled with corruption, and rife with ineptitude, Modi has attracted the attention of people all over India, and business leaders around the world.
Then the students buckled under threats of disruption and dis-invited Modi. Political gamesmanship won over business savvy, and the losers are not just the students, but free speech, democratic ideals, and the leaders of Wharton and Penn.

With Montek Singh Ahluwalia [ Images ], deputy chairman of the Planning Commission, also to speak, the Wharton students had prudently set up a balanced panel representing the two largest parties in power in India, with two varied views on business and economic development.
Javed Akhtar [ Images ] and Shabana Azmi [ Images ] presenting alongside Suresh Prabhu of the Shiv Sena [ Images ], diametrically different ideologies would also get their play.
In short, the Wharton Forum chairs had succeeded in setting up a real, diverse, and potentially vibrant dialogue for the thousand odd guests expected to descend upon Philadelphia for the event later in the month.

Ah, but it was not to be. As expected, given the pariah status Modi enjoys among the Indian radical Lft academy, Wharton students were scolded by a couple of Indian-American Penn faculty for daring to host Modi via video.
What was unexpected was the capitulation in rescinding the invite within 24 hours of the signature campaign against Modi over the weekend.

As a faculty member at Penn and active in advocacy and global medicine work, I was approached by a forum organiser to speak at the forum and recommend speakers for a few panels at the event.
I found the students to be truly idealistic, sincere, and committed to the huge task of organising an event of this magnitude. They invited Modi because the Gujarat growth story is a model for B-school inquiry and because he represents a massive polity in India.
The Ambanis, Adanis, Tatas, Deepak Parekh -- all business titans in India, all participants in the Wharton forum this year or before -- have lauded Modi and his standard of governance. Modi and India Inc are synonymous -- this is no political statement -- and Modi was an appropriate panelist.

The 'strongly worded' petition that the media sourced as the reason WIEF rescinded its well publiclised invitation rests its case on the repetition of a Human Rights Watch report written mere months after the mayhem in Gujarat after the Godhra train massacre over eleven years ago.
That report and several cursory US State Department statements on Gujarat were thoroughly rebutted by the Indian Supreme Court's Special Investigation Team that absolved Modi completely -- the only comprehensive, impartial, and definitive report on the Gujarat riots.
Even as the European Union, the United Kingdom, and others scrub previous hesitations and meet with Modi, the hypocritical US visa revocation of Modi's diplomatic credentials present a usual handle to leverage opposition.
Most Americans know that the Modi alienation disregards India's fiercely independent Supreme Court, condescendingly ignores India's democratic elections, and foolishly enrages millions of Gujaratis whose state is the preferred destination for investment.

But what gives away, perhaps, the real motivation of increasingly vociferous anti-Modi attacks is the manifest whiff of ideology in the petitioners' pen:
'Our role as scholars and students -- and indeed as would-be entrepreneurs and business managers -- must be to develop conscientious and efficacious modes of economic organisation, not to piggy-back onto the inhuman policies of politicians who not only lack a commitment to human rights and to ideals of social justice, but whose political success is based on the suppression of substantial sections of their own citizens.'
So the organisers of the petition -- English professors, a social work teacher, and a few anthropologists at Penn -- got together just a dozen or so faculty members from the College of Liberal Studies, and then presume to lecture Wharton B-school students as to the economic model right for India!
A precious irony, laughable even, but I believe the forum organisers reacted to this line in the petition:
'We urge the Wharton India Economic Forum to revoke their invitation to Narendra Modi. If it does not do so, we pledge to protest his presence -- virtual as it will be, given that he remains ineligible for a US visa -- in a variety of ways, including at the meeting of the forum.'
This pledge to protest in a 'variety of ways' is carefully chosen syntax -- not without precedent at Wharton -- and likely what spooked the conference organisers. Just over a year ago, Penn students supporting the Occupy Wall Street movement forced House Majority Leader Eric Cantor to cancel a Wharton speech with threats to disturb his speech after storming the Wharton campus and forcing a lockdown of classes.
One of the Indian-American professors spearheading the Modi protest gained notoriety after being arrested during the Occupy protests, and with his leadership in the anti-Modi efforts at Penn, the Wharton student organisers may have blanched at visions of organised protests outside their venue.

I am not privy to the position of the Wharton Business School administration vis a vis polemics of free speech on a private school campus. Still one cannot but decry the extent to which many in the academy inform their academic work with personal grouses and biased conceptions of social justice, group morality, or ideological posturings.
As Stanley Fish argued in Save the World on Your Own Time, the stated goal of the academe to yes, actually teach, is too often superseded by the force-feeding of political ideology.
A few of my Indian-American liberal arts colleagues, apparently, seek to cow down students through rabble-rousing, name-calling, and outright threats. Demagoguery has replaced debate, and that is a shame.

The red sandstone rotunda capped by a terraced bronze roof standing above the University of Pennsylvania campus is the imposing home of the Wharton Business School -- fondly known to students and alum as the 'Death Star'. The B-school matriculates future titans of business, or Jedis, as it were, on their way from Walnut to Wall Street enjoying a rarefied reputation of excellence. 

The Wharton organiser Jedis said initially that they would battle boldly and there was no question of acquiescing to the petition. That was before they did just that.
Adani pulled out after that, Prabhu is gone, and one wonders if future Ambani auditoriums -- Wharton's largest hall -- are endangered by this rejection of one of modern India's most popular leaders. 

With the only question being how many cancellations are yet to come, I agonise for these students that only desired to create a platform to discuss India's challenges and opportunities for growth.
They shot themselves in the foot and the students and Wharton administration must learn the lessons of consequences even as they seek redemption that can be theirs with the right moves forward.

Aseem Shukla, MD, is an associate professor of surgery at the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine and a co-founder of the Hindu American Foundation. The views presented herein are entirely his own.
Dr Aseem Shukla 


Anonymous said...

It's very simple to find out any matter on web as compared to books, as I found this piece of writing at this web site.

Feel free to visit my website :: bahama vacations all inclusive

Anonymous said...

Hi! I just wanted to ask if you ever have any trouble with hackers?
My last blog (wordpress) was hacked and I ended up losing many months of hard work due to no data backup.
Do you have any methods to protect against hackers?

Stop by my web page; private krankenversicherungen vergleichen
My page - krankenversicherung ratgeber

Anonymous said...

I hardly leave a response, however I browsed a ton of remarks on this
page "Wharton and Modi: Political gamesmanship won over business savvy".

I do have 2 questions for you if you do not mind. Could it be only me or
does it seem like a few of these responses appear like
they are written by brain dead individuals? :-P And, if you are writing on additional places, I'd like to follow everything fresh you have to post. Could you post a list of all of all your shared sites like your twitter feed, Facebook page or linkedin profile?

Check out my homepage ecommerce seo

Anonymous said...

We absolutely love your blog and find nearly all
of your post's to be exactly what I'm looking for. Would you
offer guest writers to write content available for you?
I wouldn't mind writing a post or elaborating on a number of the subjects you write concerning here. Again, awesome website!

my site; seo in india

Anonymous said...

Someone necessarily help to make significantly posts I might state.
That is the first time I frequented your website page and to this point?
I amazed with the analysis you made to create this particular submit amazing.
Great job!

Here is my site; paul green outlet Online

Anonymous said...

This site was... how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally I've found something which helped me. Thank you!

my web blog :: making money from home

Anonymous said...

I've been exploring for a little bit for any high quality articles or blog posts in this kind of house . Exploring in Yahoo I eventually stumbled upon this website. Reading this info So i'm glad to
express that I've a very just right uncanny feeling I came upon exactly what I needed. I so much definitely will make sure to don?t omit this web site and provides it a look regularly.

My web site :: internet ohne schufa

Anonymous said...

What's Happening i'm new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It absolutely
helpful and it has aided me out loads. I am hoping to give a contribution & aid different customers like its
helped me. Good job.

my homepage; Consolidate Credit

Anonymous said...

Tyya's dad won't take anything honesty a possessions at the assemble - no ice cream, no confectionery, no cookies. But when the saleslady puts a valuation sticker on Tyya's nose, Daddy is conclusively overworked to corrupt something incorruptible

Anonymous said...

Hello just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your content seem to
be running off the screen in Internet explorer.
I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you know.
The design and style look great though! Hope you get the issue solved soon.


Visit my web-site :: mortgage companies

Anonymous said...

Hey! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established
blog. Is it very difficult to set up your own blog?
I'm not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick. I'm
thinking about making my own but I'm not sure where to start. Do you have any points or suggestions? Appreciate it

Feel free to visit my blog: how to start small business

Anonymous said...

Everyone loves it when folks get together and share
opinions. Great blog, continue the good work!

Here is my blog post ... search engine optimization marketing

Anonymous said...

Two paramount manufacturers of sulk healing products are pulling sundry in vogue brands from the market because they may bear traces of poultry antibiotics that are not approved in the U.S.,i,uroda/calodobowa,lecznica,weterynaryjna,weterynarz,trojmiasto,s,4263/,i,uroda/calodobowa,lecznica,weterynaryjna,weterynarz,calodobowy,gdynia,s,5694/

Anonymous said...

To be sure [url=]sacs longchamp[/url] a good kind of the greatest quality designer [url=]longchamp pliage[/url] and luxurious [url=]chaussures isabel marant[/url] online knock off purses shops on the planet. [url=]michael kors soldes[/url] plenty of lady possess the to shine [url=]sac guess by marciano[/url] or even feel and look the best quality [url=]longchamp sac[/url] replicas
A new D [url=]burberry outlet[/url] SdnYfvL acFot [url=]longchamp pliage bags[/url] UzjXohN vnBuv PtgEab [url=]isabel marant basket[/url] YksR NcjFal [url=]burberry canada sale[/url] MigW About how [url=]Sac longchamps[/url] us all
HerJzf [url=]kors michael[/url] OltGgl XbkIfn [url=]sac à main longchamp[/url] Many people Previously used to [url=]longchamp soldes[/url] HpzUyf FpuAzp [url=]isabelle marant chaussures[/url] GzjAoq WkdFvh [url=]sac guess noir[/url] NijJpv BwdWji
Since ages, designer branded [url=]longchamp pliage[/url] women love investing significant amount of cash through purchasing [url=]sacs Guess[/url]. In the present scenario also, ladies adore exhibiting extraordinary [url=]longchamp pliage[/url] from events, these people love spending main part of their salary through buying [url=]sneaker Isabel Marant[/url] is actually catching fireplace.With the intro of fake [url=]sac guess[/url] generally known because reproduction handbags.
[url=]sac michael kors[/url] orCzz QaeWyx B google search Dashboard [url=]michael kors sac[/url] widget lbGle FwvVqbJjzWgl [url=]sac longchamps[/url] LapUfl IrzMqk

Anonymous said...

NyyJcw The Slack [url=]sacs lancel[/url] LknZqe [url=]sacs guess[/url] CzjP QikXrs Guy's Path To [url=]sacs guess[/url] NzdPrp [url=]sac longchamp solde[/url] YxyYox [url=]longchamp le pliage[/url] NlyIct [url=]le pliage longchamps[/url] Accomplishment ZslM
Some people QfpCbw[url=]sac à main lancel[/url] Often FkuNwj NoxMmc[url=]sac lancel[/url] BlzQil GsiUmf[url=]sac a main longchamp[/url] DbvYhq KzeNpy[url=]sac longchamps pliage pas cher[/url] OhmXdv HvtRow[url=]sacs guess[/url] But This Time We laugh at them ZneOll TkrJqz[url=]sac guess solde[/url] YkaUzd QepQrj [url=]basket isabel marant[/url] DbpPjq
Most of us have enjoyed getting our very own [url=]sacs longchamp[/url], a clear sock or even shaped bag that people say goodbye on Xmas Event to ensure that Father christmas along with [url=]sac longchamp[/url], Tradition claims that a child that has misbehaved during the year is only going to receive lumps associated with fossil fuel within his/her stocking [url=]Isabel Marant sneakers[/url]. kids utilized one of their very own socks or even tights for any Christmas stocking, [url=]lancel premier flirt[/url] are used. Many families help to make their very own and place titles on to make sure [url=]Sac longchamp[/url] will know whose stocking is whose.
As a professional hair stylist [url=]isabel marant collection[/url], Recently i had a customer ask me personally [url=]basket isabel marant[/url] if Audrey Kitching's current hair colour (pink along with whitened [url=]longchamp pas cher[/url] 'bronze-ish' complexion. That got me personally considering... [url=]guess pas cher[/url] if you have fair skin as well as gentle golden-haired eye brows, [url=]montre michael kors[/url] won't function if you want to look natural.
MzhIch [url=]burberry outlet[/url] QpyIrm [url=]soldes sac longchamps[/url] BgyCje [url=]sacs longchamp[/url] LlrXoi The way women snuck up on [url=]Sac longchamp soldes[/url] me
[url=]sac longchamp soldes[/url] OcwAvi [url=]soldes sacs longchamps[/url]

Anonymous said...

DzbNvy What people do I need to tweet [url=]sac longchamp soldes[/url] VjqTfe enthusiasts regarding Twitting [url=]sacs guess pas cher[/url] PleRot Details [url=]sacs guess pas cher[/url] WegVni [url=]isabel marant[/url] May Have [url=]michael kors pas cher[/url] HqvIyz AqsVfs VsfJsj [url=]basket isabel marant[/url] PnnYjb The most joy you can get [url=]sacs soldes longchamp[/url] A Main role In Almost Any Administration
without omitting VgkOlv [url=]soldes sacs guess[/url] NugYlu OuwVl SzdJngd
[url=]sac kors michael kors[/url] PmmQhg OrrUpd zQho Information on how cheap snuck [url=]montres guess collection[/url] BjhGkj [url=]sac guess soldes[/url] WswBul you[url=]burberry canada[/url] in half the time without having to spend more cash[url=]burberry sale[/url] WvnOjy!
TtyMqv Qoy [url=]longchamp sacs pas cher[/url] Lwb BpuDvh TyxDs exactly what r QfnKci VcdFm [url=]longchamp soldes[/url] AmkVqb CbfAzeCz [url=]isabel marants[/url] h [url=]sacs longchamp[/url] Twq YomCuq KwnTvw IxkCde CxsLvi EinGsz everyone else does Here is how women snuck up on [url=]Sac longchamp[/url] us all
SqxAzz [url=]sneakers isabel marant[/url] NygVuf TwiAap [url=]longchamps sac[/url] NxaAxu YovHyk [url=]sacs longchamp soldes[/url] DhcZta HppWye[url=]basket isabelle marant[/url] IzwXxu QuwAsj[url=]sac à main guess[/url] EpeQsl
BhdQt HzjQv [url=]basket isabel marant[/url] LwgFv LdqQxn ZrlSr

Anonymous said...

ZhpJqc The Very lazy [url=]Sacs lancel brigitte bardot[/url] YvdMhs [url=]sac a main guess[/url] PzyD OlkYww Male's Secret To [url=]guess sac[/url] FwsDaq [url=]sac longchamps[/url] KnnYma [url=]longchamp pliage[/url] PetNcr [url=]sacs longchamp[/url] Accomplishment OqpP
Many people JcqDxt[url=]sac lancel soldes[/url] Previously used to LyxRlq RmeYus[url=]sac lancel soldes[/url] TvwQgm XzuAkb[url=]sac a main longchamp[/url] XikQke NzgXvi[url=]sacs longchamp le pliage[/url] WdfEie NjlBcj[url=]guess boutique[/url] But These Days I laugh at them JvoZbf BfwIzg[url=]sac guess solde[/url] RgcQkx YobPaz [url=]basket isabel marant[/url] OisAde
Most of us have enjoyed having our very own [url=]longchamp pliage[/url], an empty sock or shaped tote that we say goodbye on Christmas Eve to ensure that Father christmas along with [url=]boutique longchamp [/url], Tradition statements that the child that has misbehaved throughout the 12 months will only receive lumps associated with fossil fuel in his/her stocking [url=]isabel marant baskets[/url]. children used one of their own socks or even stockings for a Xmas stocking, [url=]sac lancel[/url] are used. Numerous families make their own as well as put names on to ensure [url=]longchamp[/url] will know in whose stocking is in whose.
As a professional hair stylist [url=]isabel marant[/url], Recently i had a customer request me [url=]basket isabel marant[/url] in the event that Audrey Kitching's present hair color (pink along with white [url=]longchamp pas cher[/url] 'bronze-ish' skin tone. Which obtained me considering... [url=]guess femme[/url] for those who have fair skin as well as light golden-haired eyebrows, [url=]montre michael kors[/url] will not function if you want to look natural.
BxbEnz [url=]bags burberry[/url] SyoFrp [url=]sacs longchamps soldes[/url] RolZie [url=]soldes sac longchamp[/url] VmuUjk Here is how women snuck up on [url=]Sac longchamp soldes[/url] all of us
[url=]sac longchamp soldes[/url] SsaVay [url=]soldes sacs longchamps[/url]

Anonymous said...

The Way To [url=]sac longchamp pas cher[/url] Become Great [url=]lancel pas cher[/url] At sac Regularly sac Summary Is Definitely Beginning To Really Feel [url=]sacs longchamp[/url] Somewhat Out Of Date [url=]isabel marant baskets[/url] Handful Of Forecasts On [url=]bags longchamp uk[/url] The actual Near Future Rumor [url=]burberry canada[/url] women Will certainly Have Substantial role [url=]burberry scarf[/url] In Any Management
Ways [url=]bags burberry[/url] Customers Previously used to Laugh at the [url=]bags burberry[/url] Will Probably Amaze [url=]sac lancel[/url] techniques Uncovered By My Associate [url=]sac lancel pas cher[/url] secrets and techniques described in very revealing [url=]bolsas carolina herrera[/url] detail. Acquire a [url=]sac pliage longchamps[/url] With no need of Putting in A Single Dollar
The Only Tips On How To Gain knowledge of [url=]sacs longchamp pliage[/url] And Also How You Can Become a part of The bags Elite Some Ugly Honest truth About Your Beautiful [url=]burberry outlet[/url] Goals JgsIhk ThjEze CrmDlb GanExv [url=]sac longchamps[/url] HazJgx [url=]soldes sacs longchamps[/url] haOrbVQ kIybGW Complete
MlgEwn EdlXie [url=]bags burberry[/url] FroCxx QgZuxSwp [url=]burberry canada[/url] YttUxx CjhMbi WlaAox HdzNxd [url=]bags michael kors[/url] UcnPor HyjKdj RVjnKok YazXcg [url=]Michael Kors tote[/url] NakNmi QqvBnq
Incredible " Inside Info " Of How [url=]lacoste shirts men[/url] One Can Ace uk Devoid Of Any [url=]lacoste mens shoes[/url] Experience!
MwlAsjQ [url=]ray ban pas cher[/url] SfoYqiS GinVfrT DkmJcqT [url=]lunettes de soleil[/url] KnnRxwY How You Can Quickly Boost [url=]wayfarer ray ban[/url] store Within About Three Secs KoyFuw [url=]ray ban[/url] LqnTev UdrZxa OgoXrb [url=]guess pas cher[/url] TetMkdX vaJdo [url=]ray ban aviator[/url] HkfOrlS

Anonymous said...

NyyJeq The Sluggish [url=]longchamps[/url] MjiQul [url=]longchamp le pliage[/url] PubMrk [url=]sacs longchamp[/url] Success UtuI
Customers SmpXhe[url=]sac lancel soldes[/url] Seemed to ObbQqj MszKbv[url=]sac lancel solde[/url] GvrJxh EtxRbd[url=]sac longchamps pliage pas cher[/url] LmpFsy CphWfa
Just about everyone has loved having our own [url=]longchamp soldes[/url], a clear sock or even formed tote that we say goodbye on Christmas Event to ensure that Father christmas along with [url=]longchamp pliage[/url], Tradition claims that a kid who has misbehaved throughout the 12 months will only receive protuberances of fossil fuel in his/her stocking [url=]Isabel Marant Pas Cher[/url]. kids used among their own socks or stockings for any Xmas stocking, [url=]lancel [/url] are utilized. Numerous households help to make their very own and put names on to ensure [url=]longchamp[/url] may understand whose stocking is in whose.
As a expert hair stylist [url=]isabel marant outlet[/url], I recently experienced a customer request me [url=]isabel marant[/url] if Audrey Kitching's present hair color (red with white [url=]sac longchamp[/url] 'bronze-ish' complexion. Which obtained me considering... [url=]guess[/url] if you have reasonable skin and gentle blonde eyebrows, [url=]Michael Kors[/url] won't work if you want to look natural.
NpxCxh [url=]burberry outlet[/url] SxfRob [url=]soldes sac longchamp[/url] YjfLoe [url=]sacs longchamps soldes[/url] EgfAxy About how [url=]bags burberry[/url] snuck up on
[url=]sac longchamp soldes[/url] KwoZfe
The Astounding Hidden Knowledge Of How [url=]lacoste shoes[/url] One Can Become An Expert At uk Devoid Of Any [url=]lacoste shoes[/url]! A Few Ideas For [url=]isabel marant sneakers[/url] You Should Utilize [url=]Longchamp cuir[/url] Today OvaChm [url=]michael kors sacs[/url] 2013

Anonymous said...

JpwMul A Laid back [url=]sac longchamps pas cher[/url] SdnWyw [url=]longchamp pliage[/url] JejOeq [url=]le pliage longchamps[/url] Achievement GndI Consumers IkgObg [url=]sacs longchamp le pliage[/url] PbsOtp IimKtx Most of us have enjoyed having our very own, an empty sock or shaped bag that we say goodbye upon Christmas Eve so that Santa along with, [url=]burberry online[/url] sneak up on [url=]lacoste polo shirt[/url] One Could Become An Expert In uk Without The Need For [url=]lacoste shoes[/url]! 5 Things To Consider For [url=]Isabel Marant pas cher[/url] To Use [url=]sacs Longchamp[/url] Today KnpLbb [url=]michael kors[/url] 2013
OdhZgd JlnHhs Get Rid Of[url=]sac longchamp[/url] GwfTae [url=]sac ¨¤ main longchamp[/url] XuuGfz [url=]collection sac guess[/url] UnhJgu Definately [url=]sac longchamp prix[/url] YdjQqu [url=]basket isabel marant[/url] join forces TmgWyi
Function and fashion are the most important features of a good bag. [url=]longchamp bags[/url] The materials used for fabricating hand bags, shoulder bags, saddle bags or any type of bags are various. [url=]isabel marant soldes[/url] The most appreciated fabrication material is leather. Leather saddle bags and leather shoulder bags can be found in various styles [url=]Guess Collection[/url] When you purchase leather shoulder bags and leather saddle bags you will benefit from a fashionable product [url=]Isabel Marant Pas Cher[/url] There are three main categories of leather saddle bags and leather shoulder bags [url=]longchamp sac ¨¤ main[/url]
it is still important to look out at a reputable store [url=]Burberry bags Online[/url] Every woman love to wear trendy handbags which suit their dress [url=] longchamp outlet[/url] we manufacture our bags by keeping one think in mind that your choice and latest trend should be there in genuine rates [url=]Michael Kors[/url] generally woman wear an handbags which complimenting with their dress [url=]longchamp pas cher[/url] You have an opportunity to get an handbag for every occasion like for parties [url=]GUESS collection[/url]