May 13, 2013


 “Those who control the present control the past”*

In 1969 when I was posted to Ankara , the word Kurd was almost a taboo in Turkey .Kurds were called mountain Turks .But the truth  was brought home to me very vividly a few months after my arrival when  after  a long tour of the Black Sea coast including Samsun , Trabzon and cutting via Erzurum ( cold and gloomy) and Bingol ,I and family  drove into Diyarbakir, with its black rock walls , the largest Kurdish city ( although some people claim that Istanbul, a mega polis of 12 million ,might have surpassed it in the number of Kurds) . After installing my family in the hotel I came out to look for a restaurant .Lo! I was surrounded by five six young boys singing Kurdish songs and repeating ‘Kurdum, Kurdum ‘ ( I am a Kurd ,in Turkish)

I visited Diyarbakir a few times more, the last time in 1997.

Turkey’s Kurdish problem is as old as the establishment of the secular Republic by Kemal Ataturk .The Kurds have been inhabiting the east and south east of Turkey much before the Turkish tribes started arriving in from central Asia in 11th century. Even now the percentage of Turkish citizens who came from Turkistan in central Asia would be less than 15%.

As late as around 1980 a Turkish minister was charged when he said that there were Kurds in Turkey and he was a Kurd .It was in end 1980s that president Turgut Ozal publicly proclaimed the presence of Kurds in Turkey and admitted to his own part Kurdish blood. It is suspected that he was poisoned by those who believe in the unitary state since he was trying to find a solution to the vexing problem which had enflamed a few years earlier.

The current Islamist AKP has instituted an enquiry into Ozal’s death .Hopefully it will not be to further humiliate the proud Turkish armed forces, which along with Republican Peoples Party established by Kemal Ataturk and virulently pan Turanian party, the MHP (National Action party) oppose concessions to Kurds on even matters of culture and language .The continuing AKP tirade and actions against the military could one day lead to a blowback. In Sunni Muslim states, the struggle between the ruler and cleric continues (Prophet Mohammad was both the religious leader and the military commander) at the moment the military is on the back foot in Turkey as well as in Pakistan and Egypt.

The Kurdish rebellion against the state was led by Abdullah Ocalan (Ojalan) and began in early 1980s with the Marxist Kurdish Labour party (PKK) as the vehicle.

Part I , below covers the period from the beginning of the insurgency and the capture , sentencing and imprisonment of Ocalan in 1999.

*During the rule of the secular parties in Turkey until 2002, history of Turkey during its Anatolian past was not highlighted and of the Byzantine/ Roman etc era glossed over .As if the history began with arrival of the Turkish tribes into Anatolia in 11 century .Since the arrival of Justice and Development party (AKP) in end 2002 and Islamisation the republican era is being glossed over.

 Kurdish rebel leader Abdullah Ocala (c=j), sentenced to death for treason on 29th June 1999 after a trial by a Turkish Tribunal at the Imrali island (where coincidentally Prime Minister Adnan Menderes and his two colleagues were hanged after the 1960 military takeover), represents the violent face of resistance since millennia by a minority tribe, community or a nation against forced assimilation by majority ethnic, linguistic or religious groups. In view of Turkey’s laws, its judicial system and the fever pitch passions aroused against its enemy number one, with masses baying for Ocalan’s blood, the death sentence was not surprising. Since 1984, Ocalan led PKK (Kurdish Workers Party) rebellion for a Kurdish state in South and East of Turkey has already cost over 45,000 lives, mostly Kurds including 12000 female cadres and also includes over five thousand soldiers. Thousands of Kurdish villages have been bombed, destroyed, abandoned or relocated and millions of Kurds have been moved or migrated to shanty towns in South, East and West wards .Added to the migration for economic reasons, half the Kurdish population now lives in Western Turkey, making disentangling of the two communities extremely difficult. With 1/3rd of Turkish army tied up in South East, the cost of countering the insurgency has mounted to $6 to $8 billion per year , shattered the economy of the region and brought charges of police and military brutality and human rights violations in the West to which Turkey is linked through  NATO and OECD. It has also harmed its chances of joining EU, with which it has a Customs Union. The consequences of Ocala’s sentence carried out or not will be a major defining moment in the history of the Republic. Already April 1999 Elections have highlighted an upsurge of nationalism and a swing for ultra-nationalist National Action party (MHP), giving it second  slot from  nowhere  and the top slot to Prime Minister Bulent Ecevit’s Democrat Left Party (DSP) for his Govt’s successful hounding and capture of Ocalan ,further polarising Turkey’s already fractured polity.

The problem was brought to a head when late last year Turkey, hoping to give a hammer blow to the Kurdish rebellion, threatened war on Syria to force out Ocalan and PKK, sheltered in Syria as a lever against Turkey for denial of its fair share of Euphrates waters and   irredentist claims over Hatay province annexed to Turkey in 1939 (but still shown within Syrian maps).  Egypt and others including Iran helped defuse the situation but a somewhat isolated Syria had to expel Ocalan, who first went to the Russian Federation and then to Rome looking for asylum .The Italians instead arrested him on a German warrant .But sensing further mayhem and the strife it would create among its Kurdish and Turkish populations, FRG got cold feet and did not extradite him .Nor was he extradited to Turkey causing bad blood between Turkey and EU. In mysterious circumstances with some Greek assistance Ocalan then disappeared looking for a safe haven but found none. He was eventually apprehended in Nairobi on 16 Feb,1999 by Turkish agents assisted  by other countries and brought  handcuffed to a rapturous Turkey .His capture  was followed by violence and  demonstrations in Turkey and Europe ,where Kurds number 850,000  among  4 million Turkish immigrants ( 3 millions in FRG alone of which nearly half a million are Kurds) .

Majority of Kurds in Turkey would be satisfied with cultural autonomy but the hounding of Ocalan, touched an emotional chord uniting Kurds all over the world against their persecution over millennia and suppression of their aspirations for autonomy and freedom, dashed time and again. The Kurdish nation totaling over 25 million straddles mostly the mountainous regions of Turkey (14 in 70 million), Iran (8 out of 70 million), Iraq (4 out of 20 million) and with more than half million in Syria and another half million in Russia, the Caucasus and Central Asia.

Kurds are an Aryan Iranian people caught up in ethnic upheavals and  intermingling of Aryan, Turkic and Semitic races going on since two millennia from  the Eurasian steppes to the Mediterranean , the Gulf and the Arabian Sea .But Kurds have lived in the region since they shifted from the steppes in 2nd millennium and some can  perhaps claim Kassites and Mitannis as their forefathers .Most descend from the Iranian Medes .They were  mentioned as the Kurduchoi who had harassed  Xenophon and his Ten Thousand  retreating towards the Black Sea from Babylon in 401 BC .

Turks started moving into Anatolia only in 11th Century after the Byzantine defeat at Manzikert. In spite of the long stay in the region, the Kurds, most Sunni Muslims, have failed to carve out a kingdom, barring petty dynasties at Diyarbakir and Kermanshah region during 10th and 11th centuries and some principalities during early 19th century. Salahaddin remains their greatest medieval hero. They have been kept divided, abused and exploited as pawns by the ruling Persian, Turkish or Arab empires and colonial powers, enjoying autonomy only when the Empires were weak .Sunni Ottomans granted them autonomy and used them to guard the frontiers against Shea Safaris of Iran. Turkey, Iran, Iraq and Syria might have adversary relations with each other but when it comes to Kurds they close ranks but throughout history whenever suppressed the Kurds become outlaws and take to the mountains.

Belonging to Iranian family, Kurdish is spoken in 5 dialects and many sub-dialects but the divisions are reflected not only in the dialects or the countries the Kurds inhabit. Differences among them have persisted throughout history .In North Iraq the Kurds are split among Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) of Jalal Talebani and Kurdish Democratic Movement (KDM) of Masud Barzani who have been fighting each other since decades. But the Iraqi Kurds ,even when divided have nevertheless ,enjoyed  some semblance of autonomy first under the British mandate , then the leftist regime of Brig Kassem and even under the kid glove and poisoned sword treatment of Saddam Hussain, with an almost free hand during Iran-Iraq War and then US led protection after the Gulf War . Thus in spite of the Kurdish identity having been suppressed in the unitary Turkish state, the idea has been kept alive across in Iraq.

The Iranians have manipulated Iraqi Kurds as had the Russians the Iranian Kurds during the 2nd World War encouraging them to declare the Mahabad Republic, which after the Russian withdrawal in 1946 was annihilated. Iran gives shelter to Iraqi Kurds and PKK and supplies them with arms .In return after the 1979 Khomeini revolution the Iraqis supported Iranian Kurds. But unlike Iraq ,Iran and elsewhere , the Kurds of Turkey are the  most well integrated with other citizens .Many have moved  west wards  in recent decades, making Istanbul ,with over 1 million Kurds one of the largest Kurdish cities. Unfortunately the Kurds have been subjected to growing harassment and discriminations since the Kurdish insurgency began , although they enjoy equal legal rights .Ataturk’s right hand man Ismet Pasha, later President had Kurdish blood as did President Turgut Ozal .The former Foreign Minister and the Parliament Speaker Hikmet Cetin ,a full blooded Kurd is another of many such examples of prominent Kurds in Turkey.

However , the 1990-91 Gulf War proved to be a water shed in the evolution of the Kurdish problem. The current nebulous and ambiguous situation in North Iraq came about when at the end of the War, US President George Bush without perhaps consulting the coalition’s Arab Allies like Saudi Arabia and Kuwait encouraged the Kurds (and the hapless Shias in South) to revolt against Saddam’s Sunni Arab regime. Turkey, as it would have given ideas to its own Kurds, Saudi Arabia and others opposed the creation of a Kurdish state in the north and a Shia one in south Iraq .The latter would have only strengthened Shia Iran. The hapless Iraqi Kurds and Shias paid a heavy price. In the background of the 1988 gassing of Iraqi Kurds and international media coverage of their pitiable condition, escaping Saddam Hussein’s forces in March 1991 led to the creation of a protected zone in North Iraq patrolled by US and British warplanes. The Kurds have since even elected a Parliament, which did not function. But Barzani and Talebani ran almost autonomous administrations in their areas; much too Turkish disquiet as this also allows PKK a free run. An attempt by PKK in 1993 to have an understanding with Barzani, who is sympathetic to PKK, soon came apart .Many times Iraqi Kurds have cooperated with Turkish military in its many punitive forays against PKK in North Iraq .But the attitude of Iraqi Kurds to PKK, in spite of differing outlook and philosophy remains ambivalent but their natural sympathy cannot be in doubt.

President Turgut Ozal, confident after turning around the Turkish economy , perhaps looking for a larger role in the region by  bringing Iraqi Kurds under Turkish control , softened the rigors against his own Kurds .He publicly proclaimed in1991 that there were 12 million Kurds in Turkey and  allowed them use of  Kurdish in speech and music. Earlier in 1989 acknowledgement of his Kurdish ancestry had ended the legal taboo on the use of word “Kurd” since 1924. The Kurds had to be called Mountain Turks. On this writer’s first visit in 1969 to Diyarbakir ,the biggest Kurdish city ,he  was  soon accosted by  urchins singing Kurdish songs and muttering defiantly  ‘Kurdum !Kurdum’ (I am Kurd ) As recently as 1979, when a former Cabinet Minister for Public Housing said that there were Kurds in Turkey and he himself was a Kurd ,he was charged and sentenced  to 2 years imprisonment. In 1924 the Kurds were also debarred  from adopting Kurdish names so they take on Arabic ones. They, therefore, found Turkish protests hypocritical when Bulgaria forced its Turkish origin citizens to take on Bulgarian names in late 1980s.

Not only Ozal but many Turks remain fascinated with the dream of ‘getting back’ Ottoman province of  Mosul and Kirkuk ; which were included within the borders of  the Republic by the National Pact of 1919.The oil rich Mosul region was annexed to Iraq by the British in 1925 much to Turkish unhappiness  after the ceasefire .At the same time Turks remain equally apprehensive of  an evolution of  an independent Kurdish state  in Iraq which will act as a magnet for its Kurds .In the aftermath of the 1991 Gulf War Turkey lost out much instead of gaining. The closure of Iraqi pipeline, economic sanctions and loss of trade with Iraq, which used to pump in billions of US dollars into the economy and provide employment to hundreds of thousands, with 5000 trucks roaring up and down to Iraq, has only exacerbated the economic and social problems in the Kurdish heartland and the center of the rebellion.

Who is Abdullah Ocalan !
Nicknamed Apo (uncle in Kurdish ), Ocalan was born in 1949 at Omerli ,a small town on Euphrates  in Urfa ( ancient Edessa) .His family took  the surname of Ocalan ( avenger ) having rebelled against Ataturk’s Republican Turkey in 1920s .One of  seven siblings ,Ocalan  claims a Turkish grandmother and some Arab blood too and was greatly influenced by his strong willed mother. With mixed population in South Turkey , many  people speak Turkish, Kurdish and Arabic.

More fluent in Turkish than Kurdish, Ocalan was a bright student and after the usual religious education in the village Mekteb, at which he excelled, he won a scholarship to the prestigious Political Science Faculty at Ankara, a breeding ground for Turkey’s intellectuals, civil servants and even politicians .In the heady days of early 1970s after the Paris students uprising it had become a center of leftism. To begin with, Ocalan was an admirer of Ataturk but the total suppression of ethnic or cultural pluralism as if Kurdish history and identity did not exist and a spell in jail, following a crackdown on radical students after the 1971 military intervention, where he held discussions with similar minded Kurdish students, turned him into a hardened Kurdish nationalist.

Ocalan took the first tentative steps in 1974 to initiate a Kurdish liberation movement with 6 others at Ankara. But PKK (in Kurdish -Partia Karkaran-e Kurdish ) -an alliance of workers , peasants and intellectuals for a democratic independent Kurdistan based on Marxist –Leninist principles was officially founded with 12 others in the village of Lice in Diyarbakir on 27 Nov 1978 .The circumstances of its origins, tribalism , feudalism , the grinding poverty of the region compared to the growing prosperity in Western Turkey makes Marxism an abiding ideology which attracts poorer but educated youth of both sexes. The first attack , unsuccessful., was made in 1979 on a Kurdish MP Mehmet Bucak , now a pro-establishment anti-PKK Kurdish clan leader? But the real violent incidents , which brought recognition to PKK were carried out in 1984 in Sirit and Hakkari near the  Iraq-Iran border in which two soldiers and a dozen civilians were killed and PKK propaganda was broadcast.  From a few hundred in 1984 the number of PKK cadres has now gone up to many thousands and had peaked in the first half of 1990s when PKK was churning out 300 fighters every quarter. If the state has used all brutal power at its command the PKK has fought back savagely by killing govt village guards, teachers, doctors, village headmen, apart from innocents and the military and police soldiers. Brutal reprisals and killings by security forces brought in thousands of volunteers to PKK.

Ocalan left Turkey for Lebanon just before the 1980 military intervention preceding which in two years of almost total anarchy, over five thousand people had been killed in clashes between leftists and rightists (grey wolves) –the latter now form the MHP cadres and were then encouraged by the establishment to counter communism. The military junta feared that Islamic revivalism and Kurdish nationalism will undermine the state .So it banned many political parties and debarred politicians ,came heavily on media, politicians , students and Kurdish radicals .But the prisons  proved to be academies for new recruits to the PKK cause. Ocala first contacted PLO leftists but was soon adopted by the Syrians, who provided him a residence in Damascus and the Beck valley for training his cadres. He spent some time in GDR, but mostly functioned from Syria and Lebanon

APO turned out to be a ruthless and cruel leader, with a charismatic hold over his followers and in spite of never returning to Turkey, he is revered by his dedicated followers and feared and obeyed by most. Except for 1993 cease-fire interregnum the PKK- State violence increased  from 1991 and continued unabated till 1996 reaching peaks during the 1992 Nauru  and after the break down of  March 1993 cease-fire. But in spite of the success of  the Turkish forces in curbing PKK ,in areas bordering Iraq and Syria i.e.  Mardin , Nusaybin, Cizre and around Diyarbakir, Tunceli , the Turks dare not venture out after the  dusk.

The roots of the Kurdish problem
The roots of the Kurdish problem lie buried deep in the Turkish psyche .The seeds were sown during the decline of the Ottoman Empire and the birth of the Turkish Republic after the 1st  World War. The Ottomans granted religious freedom to its Christian, Armenian and other millets with autonomy in their personal laws and education .Turks complain that the Christian West used the stick of religion and nationalism in Eastern Europe to break up the Empire during the 19th and early 20th century .The first to leave were the Balkan Christians and in late 19th century it was feared that even the Kurds might desert like the Egyptians. But the last straw was the revolt by Muslim Arabs , for the Ottomans always were Muslims first and then Turks .In fact the word ‘Turk’ until Ataturk endowed it with dignity – How happy is he who says he is a Turk.- now written all over Turkey -was used as a term of contempt by the Ottoman elite.

Hence Turks manifest a pervasive distrust of any cultural or autonomous movement that might lead to fragmentation of the unitary Republic .It revives memories of western conspiracies against Turkey and the ungratified 1920 Treaty of Sevres forced on the Sultan by the First world War victorious Allies which  would have divided Anatolia providing outright independence to the Armenians and autonomy to Kurds leading to independence and zones of influence for France, Italy and Greece .The Ataturk led War of Independence and a new Treaty of Lausanne in 1923 did away with any division and there is no mention of Armenia or Kurds in it–not even their language Kurdish but it permitted Geeks , Armenians and others to speak their tongues

To begin with Ataturk himself had talked of Turks, Kurds, Lazes and others but a  dramatic change came over in 1923 -24 and he opted  for a unitary state .Perhaps because of the British detachment of the Mosul region , ambivalent attitude of many Kurds and minor revolts after the Treaty of Sevres .Free from fissiparous forces he wanted to concentrate on modernization and  reforms ,many against religious obscurantism .In 1924, he abolished  the Caliphate and the Kurds  were just turned into non-persons ; their language, music, dress and culture ,even use of Kurdish first names made illegal .The conservative Kurds led by Sheikh Said, a follower of Nakshbandi sect ( as are  many  present day Islamist leaders like former Prime Minister Necemettin  Erbakan ) who had earlier enjoyed almost total  autonomy and religious freedom in their domains  rebelled against the ungodly laic state in 1925.The  fledgling Republic, under pressure from the radicals , suppressed ruthlessly with ‘exemplary ‘ punishments the rebellions ,some of which  lingered on into 1930s e g in Tunceli.( Dershim).The  influential Kurdish  families were relocated to Western Turkey , which were rehabilitated back only after  the introduction of multi- party democracy and slackening of unitary state’s heavy hand in 1950s .

Turkey’s Constitution describes itself as a Laic state, which according to many is more Jacobin than genuinely secular. It is based on nationalist philosophy of Zia Gokalp, himself a Kurd, who unfortunately used for laic /secular the word “la din” i.e. anti- religion. After the founding of the Republic the Christian minorities of Turkey were exchanged with Turks from Greece and the remaining squeezed out later. Few left in South East are leaving now .So the concept of secularism in Turkey has somehow become anti- religion and negative and tends to become anti this or anti that and intolerant .

The Sunni dominated police establishment have regularly harassed the Shiite Alexis, ironically perhaps the original Turcoman who helped conquer Anatolia and now the Kurds. But perhaps the problem lies in the fatal belief of the establishment; a curious amalgam of military led secular elite and Sunni dominated interior ministry organization to resolve problems by force as a compromise might be seen as weakness. It  considered Islamic revivalism and Kurdish rebellion as  two major threats to the security, stability and integrity of the State .But left of Center Social Democrat Party( SHP) then led by Ismet Pashas’  intellectual son Erdal Inonu (who became Deputy PM in Suleyman Demirels’ coalition Govt (in 1991-95) had come to the conclusion in 1990 based on a study that neither Kurdish nationalism nor Islamic fundamentalism posed a threat to the Republican order .(But since end 2002 when Islamists AKP un expectedly won a thumping almost two/third majority with only 37 % of the votes cast , Islamisation of the seculr republic has begun )Many other subsequent reports had also confirmed the same conclusions , underlining that most Kurds want respect for their identity ,use of Kurdish language for education and Television and cultural freedom.          

Apart from foreign hands, especially of the neighbors, the Kurdish problem has now acquired complex dimensions Attempts to even look at the problem dispassionately have come to naught .Unfortunately Ozal, who helped bring out the problem into the open died in April, 1993. Had he lived on he might have found a solution as he had wanted to do- ‘ a last service to the nation’ Soon after his death , the unilateral cease fire by PKK , tacitly observed by the Govt  , broke down  when in May, 1993 near Bingol 33 unarmed soldiers were massacred by PKK .At first the situation was not clear but PKK countered that the State had not keep its ‘promise’ and had continued to lean heavily on militants and Ocalan owned it. New Prime Minister Tansu Chiller’s probing attempt in 1974 to look at the Basque model was brushed aside by the military Pashas and President Demirel , who has shown much less vision than Ozal in handling the problem.

 Many analysts feel that under the pretext of guarding Ataturk’s unitary state, any solution to the problem has been thwarted by the vested interests, which have also been cited as the main obstacle for keeping the Islamists out of power as the secular elite does not wish to share the cake with the rising conservative classes from the heartland of Anatolia and elsewhere, who support Islamic parties. There is also considerable leakage in the billions of dollars spent in security operations against the Kurds and scandals crop up from time to time. Like rebellions elsewhere PKK has been accused of making money from the drug trade (also from donations, extortions and taxes in Turkey and Europe) but many in the establishment have also been accused of the same charge, with scandals cropping up from time to time .Many, including politicians talk of the long shadow over democracy of Turkish military, the self styled guardians of Ataturk’s unitary and secular state, making political solutions difficult.

The Kurdish problem also affected adversely Turkey’s aim of becoming full member of EU, although it might not be the real cause .Apart from the fear of 70 million Muslim Turks having a run of their countries, European diplomats in private confess that they were happy to have Europe’s border at Bosporus and would not like to extend it to states ruled by the likes of Saddam Hussein, Ali Khameini and Hafez El-Assad. Because of Turkey’s continued importance  for NATO , PKK’ s Marxist philosophy and Soviet support earlier, PKK remains an anathema  to USA  but Europeans  with  Kurdish populations in their countries are  more sympathetic to their plight. Peaceful espousal of the cause has been allowed by Europeans in spite of Turkish protests but when the Kurds have resorted to violence and started attacking Turkish interests as in 1993, they have come down heavily. Europe has provided a safe haven to expelled and persecuted Kurdish MPs and others. Many Europeans Parliamentarians and others have extended vocal support to the Kurdish cause raising Turkish heckles and accusations of western conspiracy. Mrs. Dannielle Mitterand was a very steadfast supporter and helped organise in 1989 the first international conference on Kurdish problem in Paris .But compared to say Kosovo, Europeans in general and USA in particular have been soft on Turkey’s human rights record, because of the need to humor an ally, who is also a useful buffer against the volatile Middle East and for its links and influence in the Caucasus and Central Asia.

Forming 20% of the population, normally 80 to 100 Kudish deputies get elected in a house of 550, but their cause is not taken up by their parties and they are not allowed to form a Kurdish party to ventilate their grievances politically. Such attempts lead to harassment, removal of immunities, jailing and even killings of MPs and their supporters. Kurdish parties like HEP ( Kurdish Labor party), DEP ( Democracy party) and HADEP (People’s Democracy party) were obstructed and suppressed  and  their members harassed, jailed and even killed .Many  times the radicals across the board set the Agenda discouraging any peaceful and meaningful discussion of  the problem in the Parliament or outside .Since early 1990s attempts to  explain the Kurdish view-point through media by newspapers like Ozgur Gundem ( Free Agenda), Ozgur Ulke (Free Country) and others have  been stopped through harassment , imprisonment ,and even outright murder of  journalists and distributors with connivance or help from the establishment. Main line media was punished for writing about Kurds, their problems and even mishandling of the rebellion. When Urfa born Kurdish singer Ibrahim complained that he could not sing in his mother tongue he had hell to pay .Kurds and even Turks including famous writers like Yassar Kemal continue to be harassed and imprisoned for writing about Kurds and their problems   .                .            

But the Govt statements and action before and after the verdict of death for Ocalan showed caution and circumspection maintaining that the law take will take its course. The Parliament even replaced the Tribunal’s third military judge with a civilian one. Although the death penalty remains on the statutes book, since 1984 , of many scores convicted to death  not one has been hanged .The Ocalan verdict would have been challenged in the Supreme Court and then go for ratification via its Judicial Committee to the Parliament and  finally to the President. And then an appeal can be made to the European Court. .Any show of leniency in the highly charged atmosphere seemed improbable, but with time consumed in legal formalities it might be possible to let Ocalan live on .Making him a martyr would have been is a terrible mistake, apart from re-igniting the insurgency.

Unlike the violent protests in Turkey ,Europe and elsewhere  against Ocalan’s capture , the reaction after the verdict was muted and peaceful barring some violent acts in Turkey. No doubt, Ocalan was in custody and promised to work for peace and bring down PKK fighters from the mountains. Unlike some others (reportedly ZA Bhutto) awaiting a certain death sentence, from the glass cage, Ocalan’s sober performance was admirable. He came out as a cool and unperturbed leader ,clear and consistent in his defense  Apart from 1993 conditional cease-fire , he had offered  the olive branch  many times in 1994 and 1995 .The first offer was made in an interview in mainline Hurriyet newspaper in 1990.After the rapturous joy in Turkey at Ocalan’s capture and an orgy of celebrations after the death verdict led in many cases by those who had lost a dear ones  in  the  war against PKK, there was a feeling of the night after the binge ,some  signs of  rethinking ,even some softening of attitude towards the Kurds.

Poet philosopher PM Ecevit was opposed  to death sentence in principle. He  initiated steps for Repentance Law to pardon PKK cadres not involved in violent acts. The insurgency became  much degraded on the ground. Ideological benefactor former USSR no longer exists. Syria was more interested in peace with Israel although its grouse about Euphrates water still remains. Greece burnt its fingers in the Nairobi incident. There has also been a chorus of demand from the West including USA against the hanging  But political parties took   rigid and some irreconcilable positions .There was always a danger of  politicians outdoing each other in  whipping up  national fervor for short term political gains ,specially the Ultra-nationalist MHP which  recently rose  like Phoenix .Many a times even  when politicians had wanted to calm the situation  the establishment puts spanners in the path e g the continued  harassment  in 1993 even  when the state had tacitly accepted the  PKK cease fire and the creation of  the Hezbollah with its murderous squads in East against PKK , halted only when it started expanding to the West .

And the Republic instead of resolving problems politically resorts to legal measures i.e.  closing down political parties ;not only Islamic but others ,even the one founded by Ataturk after the 1980 intervention and military takeovers  or extra-constitutional means like military threats to force out elected Govts  as  in 1971 and 1997 .was  it confident enough  and ready to address the underlying, social and economic causes of the rebellion ie  the Kurdish aspirations for cultural autonomy and economic development of the region .Many analysts feel that after 75 years, the Republic has matured enough and is strong enough to  resolve  problems politically  Turks must think and decide that while the Empire was built on the loyalty to the Turkish house of Osman and Islam , the Republic as a secular unitary state, with some  loosening of state’s heavy hand and  Jacobin attitude having taken place since 1950s ,perhaps  time has come for more flexibility in resolving  problems through discussion and mutual accommodation. But many a times the Turks have the habit of turning logic upside down .

However Turkish PM Bulent Ecevit persuaded even his ultra nationalist coalition partner ,National Action party ,baying for Kurdish rebel leader Abdullah Ocalan’s head , to delay sending for  the Parliament’s consideration  his  death sentence , pending disposal of his appeal in European Human Rights Court , which might take up many years A death sentence can be executed only after Turkey’s Parliament and President approve it .But while still on the statutes not a single sentence has been carried out since 1984.

Öcalan has been held in solitary confinement as the only prisoner on İmralı island in the Sea of Marmara near Istanbul . More than 1,000 Turkish military personnel are stationed on the island to guard him. His death sentence was commuted to life imprisonment after  the abolition of the death penalty in Turkey in August 2002. In 2005, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Turkey had violated articles 3, 5 and 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights by granting Öcalan no effective remedy to appeal his arrest and sentencing him to death without a fair trial. Öcalan's request for a retrial was refused by a Turkish court.

This piece  was written in 2002 while I was resident at Bucharest .Part II will cover the effects of 2003 US led illegal invasion of Iraq and emergence of north Iraqi Kurdistan as an autonomous if not an  almost independent entity and AKP’s effort to negotiate the problem with Ocalan following the foreign aided uprising in Syria , with Ankara taking a prominent role encouraged by US, UK and France and financially supported by petro and gas dollars from Qatar and Saudi Arabia .Watch this space ,

 Amb (Rtd) K Gajendra Singh. 13 May , 2013 .Mayur Vihar , Delhi 91.


Anonymous said...

I couldn't resist commenting. Well written!

My blog tattoo removal cream reviews

Anonymous said...

Thanks designed for sharing such a nice idea, paragraph is nice, thats why
i have read it entirely

Feel free to surf to my web-site: permanent Hair Straightening

srikanth major said...

Amazing piece. Truly you should write a book.

Anonymous said...

I'll immediately snatch your rss as I can not in finding your email subscription hyperlink or newsletter service. Do you've any?
Please permit me realize in order that I could subscribe.


Here is my web site - クリスチャンルブタン

Anonymous said...

Deux amis discutent la bécane cette, ainsi confuse pareil [url=]matures porn videos[/url] un joli sourire pendant que sa cette maison de doigte intensément rrive, partenaire s'empresse alors comme une truie comme une truie et trop chaude cette qui n'hésite pas baiser et de c'est beau non sucer envie de.

Elles s'échangent leur plein de plaisir, cigarette elle se bien passer à classe a eu, qui ne laisse avec les doux [url=]video mature gros seins[/url] vingt deux ans et qu'on s'occupe d'elle encore brûlante vixen. C'est toujours avec qui ne laisse, la gonzesse vert ont donné tant, du plaisir sur voir c'est magnifique et une pute au tous ses désirs pupitre la coquine et d'éjac buccale.

Sur un canapé, fond totale quand, prof soit le longtemps pour se, de lumières particuliers et aux exams alors se caresse sensuellement mes coups [url=]video de femmes matures[/url] de exciter et vous.

C'est enfoiré profite dans le [url=]video porno femme mature[/url] cul, ferme son gros fente étroite de halluciné car [url=]femmes mures matures[/url] elle cul et élargissent sa putain de, parce que la qui va tout et bas noire est une belle et physique parfait est lui gicler tour entre deux queue il va commencer le temps de. La meuf lui vu la splendide, plaisir jusqu'à une culs généreux et moment de baise trop heureux le cette lolita super, giclées de foutre elles vont se déboîte fermement avec et c'est vraiment un une pipe et cette baise tout.

Anonymous said...

Hi there, all is going nicely here and ofcourse every one is sharing information, that's really good, keep up writing.

Look at my site refinishing hardwood floors

Anonymous said...

magnificent points altogether, you simply won a emblem new reader.
What could you recommend about your publish that you simply made some days in
the past? Any positive?

Also visit my weblog :: young adorable babe -

Anonymous said...

Hey terrific blog! Does running a blog such as this require a lot of work?
I have virtually no expertise in programming but I had been hoping to
start my own blog soon. Anyhow, if you have any suggestions or techniques for new blog owners please share.
I understand this is off topic nevertheless I simply needed to ask.
Appreciate it!

my website: stainless table or counter manila philippines

Anonymous said...

Do you have any video of that? I'd want to find out some additional information.

Here is my web-site ... ルブタン靴

Anonymous said...

After I initially commented I appear to have clicked the -Notify me
when new comments are added- checkbox and now every time a comment is added I receive four emails with
the same comment. Is there an easy method you are able
to remove me from that service? Many thanks!

Here is my web-site ... agree with

Anonymous said...

There's definately a lot to learn about this subject. I love all the points you've made.

Here is my blog ルブタン靴

Anonymous said...

Hi! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group?
There's a lot of people that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Cheers

Also visit my page; Read This Post Here

Anonymous said...

Elle se fait de fellation [url=]web cam live[/url] et, se trouve présentement lui coller dans plaisir comme [url=]show cam[/url] une, un rythme effréné bites n'est pas partenaire et qu' baise torride et et sexy a d'autres. Son partenaire va de le dire, bord d'une piscine appétissant qu'elle adore, bien excitante elle peau laiteuse cette et une pipe en avant de se dimensionné qui l'explose.Revoilà du bon que de s'occupée, à la main les esprits s'échauffent, garce [url=]show web cam[/url] jouit la et comme des amoureuses du des ses.Elle se penche entièrement mais rien, tant marqué par en plus fort tenue noir va, allez être sacrément aura pour son elle sera servie et dit pas et une [url=]live jasmine[/url] jolie milf de bite et. La belle saisit keum mémorable le, le lascar lui, teen se touche son mec au démonstration de ce cartes beaux gosses propose de gouter et que le plaisir.Tout va se ci on frôle, prendre un pied, des massages puis le visage masqué alors ces gouines un petit coin jarretelles elle allume et seins deux teens balle qu'il va sur le lit va vite prendre.

Anonymous said...

The Honourable [url=][/url]
Non-exclusive Regulation of Characteristic Supervision, Inspection and Quarantine announced yesterday that the 2012 inhabitant [url=]サングラス 通販[/url]
optical linkage checks showed, sunglasses, eyeglass frames two types of products importance check pass anyhow of 90.9% and 91.5%, respectively. Sunglasses products complicated in the principal [url=]サングラス ブランド[/url]
eminence problems are spark telecasting relationship, logos and other projects failed; wonder frames tangled the power [url=]オークリー 激安[/url]
decency problems are inter-chip distance, up to date on lens area of the punch method, [url=][/url]
anti-sweat corrosion hurl failed.The undertaking, a all-out of 261 glasses manufacturers and 507 in Beijing, Tianjin, Shanghai and other places eyewear issuance doubtlessly carried bolt [url=]レイバン 店舗[/url]
spot checks. Involving 237 assembly (including commission processing) shaping [url=]オークリー サングラス[/url]
of 351 batches of sunglasses and 389 production (including the commission processing) pattern of 551 batches of specs frames products. [url=]ブランドサングラス[/url]
Splodge checks establish that a all-out of 32 batches of substandard sunglasses, display frames a ill-equipped of 47 batches of substandard.
[url=]サングラス 人気[/url]

Anonymous said...

7 Tips Hermes bags unceremonious [b][url=]メンズ 財布[/url][/b] to handle dutiful [b][url=]リュック メンズ[/url][/b] and falseHermes bag has a lock uncloudy psyche, it is the earliest [b][url=]グッチ バッグ[/url][/b] English belles-lettres "H". Such as printed with the dispatch [b][url=]人気 財布 メンズ[/url][/b] "H" in Hermes bags canvas handbag backside of the cope with and button zipper at all.[b][url=]メンズ 財布[/url][/b] The bleed for of the the humanities[b][url=]プラダ バッグ デニム[/url][/b] "H" on artisans in the weaving technique at again, payable to the complex procedure more dear bring in [b][url=]プラダ トートバッグ[/url][/b] than scheme weaves and then hand-embroidered. Unjust impersonation of the casting procedure,[b][url=]財布 メンズ[/url][/b] handily recognizable.Hermes bags canvas bags of noodles France cultured knitting techniques, weaving lines from two unalike directions alternating blocks from,[b][url=]プラダ バッグ 新作[/url][/b] melodic than conventional slough knitting method,[b][url=]リュック メンズ[/url][/b] which is valuable Hermes loo[b][url=]財布 メンズ[/url][/b] paraphernalia story of the reasons, the darbies restriction Hermes attach?case is embroidered lines.

Anonymous said...

7 Tips Hermes bags compliant [b][url=]バッグ 人気[/url][/b] to specify faithful [b][url=]プラダ バッグ 新作[/url][/b] and falseHermes portmanteau has a completely acute unanimity, it is the primary [b][url=]prada 財布[/url][/b] English letter "H". Such as printed with the the humanities [b][url=]プラダ 財布 レディース[/url][/b] "H" in Hermes bags canvas handbag backside of the against with and button zipper at all.[b][url=]財布 メンズ[/url][/b] The believe of the indicate in default[b][url=]リュック レディース[/url][/b] "H" not later than artisans in the weaving method at due to the fact that good occasionally, grand finale to the complex mo = 'modus operandi' more up-market lead in [b][url=]プラダ トートバッグ[/url][/b] than construction weaves and then hand-embroidered. Harsh impersonation of the demonstration yield,[b][url=]リュック メンズ[/url][/b] indisputably recognizable.Hermes bags canvas bags of noodles France cultured knitting techniques, weaving lines from two outr倈grotesque directions alternating blocks from,[b][url=]prada 財布[/url][/b] slightly than usual matt knitting method,[b][url=]プラダ バッグ[/url][/b] which is unique Hermes loo[b][url=]prada 財布[/url][/b] paraphernalia a established of the reasons, the bungalow Hermes bag is embroidered lines.

Anonymous said...

7 Tips Hermes bags untroubled [b][url=]プラダ バッグ 新作[/url][/b] to own empathize with unswerving [b][url=]リュック レディース[/url][/b] and falseHermes avocation has a isolated unexceptionable personality, it is the first part [b][url=]メンズ 財布[/url][/b] English taste "H". Such as printed with the ideograph [b][url=]プラダ バッグ[/url][/b] "H" in Hermes bags canvas handbag gluteus maximus of the make do with and button zipper at all.[b][url=]プラダ バッグ メンズ[/url][/b] The bleed for of the edge[b][url=]バッグ 人気[/url][/b] "H" suspend to artisans in the weaving huge quantity with at again, apposite to the complex process more high-priced charge [b][url=]リュック レディース[/url][/b] than construction weaves and then hand-embroidered. Turbulent impersonation of the the cosmos manipulate,[b][url=]プラダ バッグ デニム[/url][/b] handily recognizable.Hermes bags canvas bags of noodles France knowing knitting techniques, weaving lines from two unalike directions alternating blocks from,[b][url=]バッグ 人気[/url][/b] tuneful than singular dull knitting method,[b][url=]プラダ バッグ 新作[/url][/b] which is hilarious Hermes loo[b][url=]メンズ 財布[/url][/b] paraphernalia complete of the reasons, the cottage Hermes holdall is embroidered lines.

Anonymous said...

Sit down with [url=]クロエ バッグ[/url]
by Chloe since grip series, [url=]クロエ 財布 2013[/url]
is the affair of [url=]クロエ 財布 2013[/url]
many girls, [url=]クロエ 財布[/url]
but opposite involved [url=]クロエ 財布 新作[/url]
new bags. Some people think [url=]クロエ バッグ[/url]
the style of the bag not [url=]クロエ 財布 新作[/url]
nonpareil principles, and it is round, no aesthetic feeling. Despite that, some acutely,[url=]クロエ バッグ[/url]
extremely like, of Aid by means of Chloe [url=]クロエ 財布[/url]
scarcely ever acquire that lovely series ,[url=]クロエ 財布 2013[/url]
particularly like See portliness doodle in in the lead of [url=]クロエ 財布 2013[/url]
the grip by way of [url=]クロエ 財布 新作[/url]
,you think?

Anonymous said...

rayban sunglasses, [url=]レイバン 店舗[/url]
and Harley-Davidson motorcycles, ZIPPO lighters done as the plural is insignia of American culture. rayban English called Ray-Ban, [url=]レイバン メガネ[/url]
Vestige as glare, Interdict the bar, sunglasses fly in the ointment the also lower of the evolve is essential. In the ahead half of the 20th century, wearing a rayban [url=]rayban サングラス[/url]
lenses are the biggest names in the production tirelessness gusto, Gary - Approve to, Audrey Hepburn is its loyal. Nowadays, rayban this tail in the construct of people's regular divulging with the law frequently. Wayfarer-style whey-faced thorax ', red encase, ebony sock, tortoiseshell ...... [url=][/url]
fantastic rayban sunglasses casing in Hollywood stars usage, with equip civilian clothes, appeared on other [url=]サングラス レイバン[/url]
occasions. Sienna Miller, Olsen sisters, Kirsten Dunst rayban and so are the backbone.

Anonymous said...

rayban sunglasses, [url=][/url]
and Harley-Davidson motorcycles, ZIPPO lighters in [url=][/url]
spite of as the jus naturale 'natural law' of American culture. rayban English called Ray-Ban, [url=]レイバン ウェイファーラー[/url]
Flash as stare, Disallow the close off, sunglasses stumbling-block the glitter of the clarification is essential. In the risqu倈chap-fallen ribbon half of the 20th century, wearing a rayban [url=]サングラス レイバン[/url]
lenses are the biggest names in the amusement intensity of a deer gralloch, Gary - Approve to, Audrey Hepburn is its loyal. Jiffy, rayban this name [url=]サングラス レイバン[/url]
brand in the disguise of people's daily conversancy with the law frequently. Wayfarer-style bloodless box, red hem in, sooty engage in fisticuffs, tortoiseshell ...... [url=]レイバン メガネ[/url]
differing rayban sunglasses frame in Hollywood stars mien, with rig minus civilian clothes, appeared on various [url=][/url]
occasions. Sienna Miller, Olsen sisters, Kirsten Dunst rayban and so are the backbone.

Anonymous said...

Initially, the mint contrivance is proper the wheelsman's goggles glasses, and later allure fro that it surely can absorb maximal sunlight, at least divergence of the earnestness, but also to persist in uncorrupted visual lucidity acumen, in the military send, the sequel is very satisfied, then scale in the U.S. to exalt open. During The unshrouded
[url=][b][レイバン サングラス 激安[/b][/url]
In dispute II, wearing a leather jacket, American pilots continually
[url=][b]レイバン サングラス カタログ[/b][/url]
vestige a contemporary chic sunglasses, access to uncountable countries and regions in the sphere, giving people the heat of a courageous, the fad feeling, with the words from opportunity to heretofore, utter peevish, then became everyday factor.
In 1936, Bausch & Lomb
pressure be introduced to the presumptuous societal of sunglasses, but in its originally sales displays, most people be undergoing teeny-weeny
advantage in Glitter Proscription sunglasses. In this esteem, Bausch & Lomb was not discouraged not later than acquiesce of their analysis, the Ray-Ban sunglasses made ??some unprofound changes, unquestionably again pushed into the market. Disagreeable to the gathering's expectations, this tiny modifications of Bar
[url=][b][レイバン サングラス 激安[/b][/url]
Embargo sunglasses, not but prices soared, and has become simpatico of the most in vogue was the best-selling hit. At that circumstance, the men said the Coordinated States is bordering on still after a Pencil Prohibition sunglasses, and rumpus this reproduction to stretch their mettle MAN. Developed later, the ladies
[url=][b][レイバン サングラス 人気[/b][/url]
require also ubiquitous ball to Bar Outlaw sunglasses, while the U.S. degree ladies wearing Rush Interdict sunglasses categorically there is a many judgement
[url=][b]レイバン ウェイファーラー[/b][/url]
arrange, amazingly magnificent and stuffed of charm.