September 17, 2014
Grouping. Grouping (and its corollary, Establishing Relationships) is probably the most useful of the convergent thinking techniques. In order to get a handle on all of the ideas that typically emerge from any divergent thinking exercise, it is important to be able to group similar ideas or hypotheses together. Critical to this effort are the labels assigned to the various groups. All sorts of cultural and cognitive biases can easily come into play with poorly chosen group names (For example, think how easily the labels "terrorist", "freedom fighter", "good" or "evil" can influence future analysis). Mindmapping and other concept mapping techniques are very useful when attempting to use grouping as a way to deal with an overabundance of ideas.
Prioritizing. Deciding which ideas, concepts or hypotheses deserve the most emphasis is crucial if collection and analytic resources are to be used efficiently. Treating every idea as if it is equal to all the others generated by the divergent thinking process makes no sense. Yet, as with any convergent thinking process, the decision regarding which concept is first among the putative equals should be made carefully. Problems typically arise when the team setting the priorities is not diverse enough. For example, a team of economists might well give economics issues undue emphasis.
Filtering. Filtering, as a convergent thinking technique, explicitly recognizes the awful truth of intelligence analysis - there is never enough time. Filtering can be used to eliminate, in its extreme application, some possibilities entirely from further consideration. Typically, however, analysts will use filtering to limit the level and extent of collection activities. For example, intel professionals looking at pre-election activity in a certain country might decide to focus their collection activities at the county rather than at the city or town level. As with grouping and prioritizing, where to drawn these kinds of lines is fraught with difficulty and should not be done lightly.
Posted by Naxal Watch at 3:36 AM