Skip to main content

India: State and Its Anxiety of Caste Census


Acknowledging the fact of caste through census reveals the truth of anxiety.

 

The idea of caste census by the colonial rulers had both constraining as well as enabling sight. It was constraining to the extent that it was designed to bring certain sections, such as sex workers, prisoners and patients suffering from contagious diseases, under the surveillance of the colonial administration. The enabling sight of the colonial census operation was discernible in particular respect to the Untouchable castes. Colonial census that used anthropological parameters to cover these castes not only brought their predicament in the national focus, but it also helped Untouchable leaders to approximate the social reality of untouchability at the national level. Put differently, through print and wireless media, the enumeration of caste census generated a pan-Indian social consciousness among the Untouchables.

The central government of free India, for distributive purposes, continued all-India census for the Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs). However, the rising desperation and depression that has been increasingly faced by several castes seems to have led the leaders of these castes to demand caste census so that the case for state attention to the problems of these castes could be legitimately made. These parties are demanding the enumerative mention of caste in government records just like the SCs and STs. However, it is both the central government as well as some academicians, who, for different reasons, do not favour the idea of extending caste census to castes other than SCs and STs. What are the grounds of such scepticism to caste census?

Scholars with liberal/radical orientation seem to use universal argument that, by consequences, might deflect policy attention from comprehending human development index. From this perspective, then, data on human development index becomes much more important than the data on caste. Thus, such argument assumes abstractly countable individual, such as citizen or poor, as a reference point rather than sociologically and hence concretely situated person in the caste. These scholars, how­ever, ignore the connection between caste and development, which are mutually constraining, as they do not address the following questions. For example, how does one account for the disproportionate distribution of opportunities favouring one caste rather than another? If the argument for the defence of disproportionate distribution is, as is the case more often than not, attributed to competitive merit even then one needs to ask further question: Is merit devoid of favourable conditions that have historically enabled some castes to retain their privileged position in the distribution of opportunities? Even for a developing index that is sensitive to human development, we need to accurately know which castes, apart from SC and ST, are forced to do inferior and degrading jobs. In order to draw the exact account of deprivation index, we need totality of caste figures.

The liberal/modernist, on the other end of the spectrum, see in a caste-based census a lurking danger of essentialism. According to such line of thinking, the demand for caste census, which is primarily driven by the need to gain distributive benefits from the government, would eventually make caste an essential source of progress. Caste census as the single parameter of distribution of reservation, in fact, undermines the logic of essentialism. Put differently, it, instead of perpetuating caste, seeks to undermine it through internal differentiation induced by intra-group inequality which itself is the result of skewed implementation of reservation policy. In a dialectical sense, the demand for caste census by the Other Backward Class (OBC) leaders actually promises this internal differentiation.

However, we need to raise the question: Why is government sceptical of either undertaking the operation of caste census or making public caste-based figures that are supposed to be already available? Among other reasons, the important reasons could be that the government may not want to confront the fact of caste that causes moral embarrassment both within and outside the country and, hence, the acute need for avoiding official enumeration of caste. Castes, however, are not abstract or an innocent entity, in fact, they are concrete facts that play out through social practices. The analysis and interpretation of such facts play an important role in producing truth of discrimination and domination both across and within castes.

However, those who represent the government tend to use the fact of caste as rhetoric rather than truth. For example, those in power have been frequently using caste numbers as the source for gaining legitimacy as a political need. Thus, the claim to have given ministerial berth to more members from the OBC and SC forms part of the rhetoric. But such claims of being the government of the subaltern castes is seldom the government for the millions of OBCs or SCs who are almost mired in disadvantage and depression. The rhetoric which necessarily feeds itself on the fuzzy rather than census-based identity of the OBC helps the government in power to avoid acknowledging the internal inequality within caste groups. Arguably, the caste-based census promises to ground the truth of internal inequality. Any government which is committed to producing a healthy and robust society would not shy away from acknowledging, through caste census, the fact of caste as truth and not as rhetoric.


https://www.epw.in/journal/2021/33/editorials/state-and-its-anxiety-caste-census.html

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Menon meets Karzai, discusses security of Indians

Kabul/New Delhi/Washington, March 5 (IANS) India Friday said that the Feb 26 terror attack in Kabul will not deter it from helping rebuild Afghanistan as National Security Adviser Shivshankar Menon met Afghan President Hamid Karzai in Kabul to review the security of around 4,000 Indians working in that country. Menon, who arrived here Friday morning on a two-day visit, discussed with Karzai some proposals to bolster security of Indians engaged in a wide array of reconstruction activities, ranging from building roads, bridges and power stations to social sector projects. The Indian government is contemplating a slew of steps to secure Indians in Afghanistan, including setting up protected venues where the Indians working on various reconstruction projects will be based. Deploying dedicated security personnel at places where Indians work is also being considered. Menon also met his Afghan counterpart Rangin Dadfar Spanta and enquired about the progress in the probe into the Kabul atta

Iran is losing the game to regional actors in its strategic depth

Rethink before It’s Too Late http://www.irdiplomacy.ir/index.php?Lang=en&Page=21&TypeId=15&ArticleId=7108&BranchId=19&Action=ArticleBodyView Iran is losing the game to regional actors in its strategic depth –Afghanistan. By Houman Dolati It is no more a surprise to see Iran absent in Afghanistan affairs. Nowadays, the Bonn Conference and Iran’s contributions to Afghanistan look more like a fading memory. Iran, which had promised of loans and credit worth five-hundred million dollars for Afghanistan, and tried to serve a key role, more than many other countries, for reconstruction and stabilization of Afghanistan, is now trying to efface that memory, saying it is a wrong path, even for the international community. Iran’s empty seat in the Rome Conference was another step backward for Afghanistan’s influential neighbor. Many other countries were surprised with Iran’s absence. Finding out the vanity of its efforts to justify absence in Rome, Iran tried to start its

Pakistani firm whose chemicals were used to kill US troops seeks subsidy for Indiana plant

By Jennifer Griffin, Justin Fishel Published March 22, 2013   A Pakistani fertilizer maker whose chemicals have been used in 80 percent of the roadside bombs that have killed and maimed American troops in Afghanistan is now seeking U.S. taxpayer subsidies in order to open a factory in Indiana.  The request appears to be on hold pending further review, but the situation has stirred outrage in Congress, where some accuse the Pakistani government of halting efforts to clamp down on the bomb-making.  For the past seven years, the U.S. government has known that the raw material calcium ammonium nitrate, or CAN, is making its way across the border into Afghanistan where the Taliban use it to fuel their most deadly weapons, namely the improvised explosive device. IEDs have long been the number one killer of U.S. and coalition troops.  The material largely comes from Pakistani fertilizer maker the Fatima Group. But the Pakistani government has stymied attempts by the Pentagon to stop the